<105W over 13 results

By: blue (blue.delete@this.blue.com), March 18, 2017 8:02 pm
Room: Moderated Discussions
juanrga (no.delete@this.juanrga.com) on March 18, 2017 12:32 pm wrote:
> blue (blue.delete@this.blue.com) on March 16, 2017 9:22 pm wrote:
>
> > Overall, this ranting about TPD is pointless. For most (all?) consumers it is beneficial on
> > desktop/plugged in laptops. For Server players it is a nonissue as they will be able to control
> > the hardpower limited on the chips (or at least MCMs) themselves. And will choose to purchase
> > (or not) Zen architecture products based on if that pref/watt clockspeed*IPC provides enough
> > ST and/or MT performance compared to Intel (and possibly the upcoming ARM competition).
> >
>
> Yeah, before launch TDP did matter a lot of and forums, including this, were
> filled with BS about how much more efficient Ryzen was compared to Broadwell.
>
> Now that reviews killed all the pre-launch hype and BS marketing, then now TDP doesn't matter anymore.
>
> In any case, let me emphasize again that the main point is about how AMD tried
> to fool us with marketing TDP figures that don't represent the real TDP.
>
> We know the real TDP of the 1800X is ~130W, not 95W. And CanardPC has
> just confirmed that the real TDP of the 1700 model is 90W not 65W.
>
> https://twitter.com/CPCHardware/status/843109717610287105

Why do you insist on using ~130W? It's 128W max.

And most reviews I have seen show about a 120-130W difference from idle to CPU only load for the system, which should be in the 100-115W range depending on the PSU rating.

More than 95W? Yes. Absolutely. 130W? Absolutely not.

a bunch of numbers from various reviews:
1@ direct CPU draw, ~112W draw max at stock.
13@ wall difference between idle and CPU load:
125.5W
126W
109.5W
125W
97W
125W
128W
121W
110W
176W
139W
114W
126W


Seems to me most of the difference in system draw is 120-130W from the wall, sans about 20%, or about 100-110W.
Taking the average of the 13 system results with 85% efficency PSU leads to about 106W.
Throwing out the insane 176W and low 97W figures gives 104.5W at 85% PSU efficency.
102.5W with 97W figure included and 176W not included.

So, basically <105W for the CPU from idle to load. Which could be even less if PSU efficency was lower. And most reviewers tend to use overkill PSUs. So I think that <100W maybe true on average.
< Previous Post in ThreadNext Post in Thread >
TopicPosted ByDate
Intel's underwhelming core innovationsAshraf Eassa03/04/17 11:17 PM
  Intel's underwhelming core innovationsAdrian03/05/17 12:17 AM
    Intel's underwhelming core innovationsanon03/05/17 02:25 AM
      Intel's underwhelming core innovationsAdrian03/05/17 11:37 AM
        Intel's underwhelming core innovationsanon03/05/17 11:51 AM
        Intel's underwhelming core innovationsSeni03/05/17 01:44 PM
          Intel's underwhelming core innovationsanonymou503/05/17 07:07 PM
          Intel's underwhelming core innovationsAdrian03/06/17 01:20 AM
        Intel's underwhelming core innovationsDoug S03/05/17 03:45 PM
          Intel's underwhelming core innovationsAdrian03/06/17 01:30 AM
            Intel's underwhelming core innovationsJukka Larja03/06/17 08:51 AM
              Intel's underwhelming core innovationsTravis03/06/17 11:35 AM
                Intel's underwhelming core innovationsBigos03/06/17 11:44 AM
                  Intel's underwhelming core innovationsTravis03/06/17 03:49 PM
                Intel's underwhelming core innovationsGabriele Svelto03/06/17 02:38 PM
                  Intel's underwhelming core innovationsTravis03/06/17 03:46 PM
                    Intel's underwhelming core innovationsMaynard Handley03/06/17 05:10 PM
                      Intel's underwhelming core innovationsTravis03/06/17 09:07 PM
                        Intel's underwhelming core innovationsMaynard Handley03/07/17 10:23 AM
                      Intel's underwhelming core innovationsJukka Larja03/07/17 10:26 AM
                    Intel's underwhelming core innovationsGabriele Svelto03/07/17 02:09 AM
                      Intel's underwhelming core innovationsMichael S03/07/17 03:05 AM
                        Intel's underwhelming core innovationsGabriele Svelto03/07/17 05:18 AM
                          Intel's underwhelming core innovationsVertexMaster03/07/17 07:28 AM
                            Intel's underwhelming core innovationsJukka Larja03/07/17 10:09 AM
                              Intel's underwhelming core innovationsanon03/07/17 11:20 AM
                              Intel's underwhelming core innovationsVertexMaster03/07/17 11:31 AM
                                Intel's underwhelming core innovationsGabriele Svelto03/07/17 02:37 PM
                            Intel's underwhelming core innovationsGabriele Svelto03/07/17 02:32 PM
                              Intel's underwhelming core innovationsVertexMaster03/07/17 03:06 PM
                                Intel's underwhelming core innovationsMaynard Handley03/07/17 04:41 PM
                                Intel's underwhelming core innovationsJukka Larja03/08/17 08:33 AM
                                  Intel's underwhelming core innovationsVertexMaster03/08/17 05:44 PM
                                    Intel's underwhelming core innovationswumpus03/09/17 07:28 AM
                                    Intel's underwhelming core innovationsJukka Larja03/09/17 08:04 AM
                Intel's underwhelming core innovationsJukka Larja03/07/17 10:35 AM
              Intel's underwhelming core innovationsMichael_S03/06/17 01:43 PM
                Intel's underwhelming core innovationsJukka Larja03/07/17 08:47 AM
          Intel's underwhelming core innovationsGabriele Svelto03/06/17 01:57 AM
    Intel's underwhelming core innovationsGabriele Svelto03/05/17 02:30 AM
      Intel's underwhelming core innovationsJouni Osmala03/05/17 10:30 AM
        Intel's underwhelming core innovationsTravis03/05/17 12:15 PM
        Intel's underwhelming core innovationsGabriele Svelto03/05/17 12:41 PM
          Intel's underwhelming core innovationsJouni Osmala03/07/17 12:24 AM
  Back to futureMichael S03/05/17 03:30 AM
    Back to futureTravis03/05/17 12:21 PM
  Intel's underwhelming core innovationsAlberto03/05/17 02:36 PM
    Intel's underwhelming core innovationsanon03/05/17 03:21 PM
      Intel's underwhelming core innovationsTravis03/05/17 04:07 PM
        Intel's underwhelming core innovationsanon03/05/17 05:07 PM
          Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerVertexMaster03/05/17 05:45 PM
            Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerDavid Kanter03/05/17 06:53 PM
              Ryzen vs BroadwellE Poweritsmydamnation03/05/17 09:30 PM
                My Firefox shows blank frames in place of results (NT)Michael S03/06/17 03:20 AM
                Ryzen vs BroadwellE Power - More DataVertexMaster03/06/17 07:25 AM
                  Ryzen vs BroadwellE Power - More DataAlberto03/06/17 02:23 PM
                    Ryzen vs BroadwellE Power - More DataKalelovil03/06/17 02:40 PM
                    Ryzen vs BroadwellE Power - More Datablue03/06/17 03:55 PM
              Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerDoug S03/05/17 11:42 PM
                Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerBrett03/06/17 01:21 AM
                  You still are. (NT)Megol03/06/17 08:53 AM
              Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerHans de Vries03/06/17 02:51 AM
                Ryzen vs BroadwellE Powerjuanrga03/06/17 12:47 PM
              Ryzen vs BroadwellE Poweranon03/06/17 06:09 AM
                Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerMichael S03/06/17 07:50 AM
                  Ryzen vs BroadwellE Poweranon03/06/17 08:09 AM
                    Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerMichael S03/06/17 08:31 AM
                      Ryzen vs BroadwellE Poweranon03/06/17 08:58 AM
                        Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerMichael S03/06/17 10:09 AM
                          Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerBlue03/06/17 10:22 AM
                            Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerMichael S03/06/17 10:42 AM
                              Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerAdrian03/07/17 02:44 AM
                                Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerMichael S03/07/17 03:11 AM
                                  Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerAdrian03/07/17 04:05 AM
                                    Naples presentation published at servethehome.com (NT)Adrian03/07/17 07:47 AM
                                      Naples presentation published at servethehome.comAdrian03/07/17 08:07 AM
                          Ryzen vs BroadwellE Powergallier203/06/17 10:31 AM
                          Ryzen vs BroadwellE Poweranon03/06/17 12:37 PM
              Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerFoyle03/06/17 06:17 AM
              Ryzen vs BroadwellE Powerjuanrga03/06/17 12:25 PM
                Ryzen vs BroadwellE Powerhobel03/08/17 02:13 AM
                  Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerMichael S03/08/17 03:11 AM
                  Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerSimon Farnsworth03/08/17 04:50 AM
                  Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerAdrian03/08/17 06:11 AM
                    Ryzen vs BroadwellE Powerhobel03/08/17 06:47 AM
                      Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerTravis03/08/17 01:47 PM
                    Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerWilco03/08/17 04:08 PM
                      Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerAdrian03/09/17 03:29 AM
                      Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerAdrian03/09/17 03:58 AM
                    Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerRicardo B03/12/17 11:54 AM
                  Ryzen vs BroadwellE Powerjuanrga03/09/17 12:52 PM
                  Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerDavid Hess03/09/17 07:14 PM
                  Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerRicardo B03/12/17 11:42 AM
                AMD admits 128W and 90W real TDP for RyZenjuanrga03/25/17 06:34 AM
                  Coud you please stop your bullshit?Heikki Kultala03/25/17 07:25 AM
                    X399 official TDP 180W (>200W real TDP)juanrga03/25/17 09:17 PM
                      wow that's a lot for a chipset (NT)Eric Bron03/28/17 02:49 AM
                  I already wrote that, why can't you read?anon03/26/17 01:48 AM
                    AMD admits 128W and 90W real TDP for RyZenjuanrga03/26/17 04:44 AM
                      I love how you went to the effort of changing the topic back, you child. (NT)Anon03/26/17 06:40 AM
                      You don't have any idea about thermodynamics eitheranon03/26/17 09:32 AM
                        You don't have any idea about thermodynamics eitherAlberto03/27/17 05:39 AM
                          You don't have any idea about thermodynamics eitherjuanrga04/01/17 05:19 AM
                        You don't have any ideajuanrga04/01/17 05:45 AM
                          You don't have any ideaanon04/01/17 08:39 AM
                      AMD admits 128W and 90W real TDP for RyZenhobel03/27/17 08:20 AM
                        AMD admits 128W and 90W real TDP for RyZenMegol03/30/17 09:23 AM
            Ryzen vs BroadwellE Powerjuanrga03/06/17 12:35 PM
              Ryzen vs BroadwellE Poweranon03/06/17 12:45 PM
                Ryzen vs BroadwellE Powerjuanrga03/06/17 12:59 PM
                  Ryzen vs BroadwellE Poweranon03/06/17 01:10 PM
                    Ryzen vs BroadwellE Powerjuanrga03/06/17 06:20 PM
                      Ryzen vs BroadwellE Poweranon03/07/17 02:38 AM
                        Ryzen vs BroadwellE Powerjuanrga03/07/17 05:35 AM
                          Ryzen vs BroadwellE Poweranon03/07/17 06:03 AM
                            Ryzen vs BroadwellE Powerjuanrga03/07/17 11:28 AM
                              Ryzen vs BroadwellE Poweranon03/07/17 12:07 PM
                                Ryzen vs BroadwellE Powerjuanrga03/07/17 04:34 PM
                                  Ryzen vs BroadwellE Poweranon03/07/17 04:59 PM
                                    Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerAlberto03/08/17 04:59 PM
                                      Ryzen vs BroadwellE Poweranon03/09/17 03:33 AM
                                        Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerAlberto03/09/17 07:50 AM
                                          bullshit on ryzen apu release timeheikki kultala03/09/17 09:18 PM
                                            Problems in mobile line.....shhhhhAlberto03/11/17 12:54 AM
                                          Ryzen vs BroadwellE PowerMatthias Waldhauer03/11/17 03:21 PM
                                            Timelines? What timelines?juanrga03/12/17 05:40 AM
                                              Timelines? What timelines?Matthias Waldhauer03/26/17 09:31 AM
                                                Timelines? What timelines?juanrga04/01/17 05:23 AM
                                      Ryzen vs BroadwellE Powermuziqaz03/09/17 04:12 AM
                                        Ryzen vs BroadwellE Powerjuanrga03/09/17 12:47 PM
                                          Ryzen vs BroadwellE Powermuziqaz03/10/17 06:52 AM
                                            Ryzen fiascojuanrga03/11/17 04:01 AM
                                              Ryzen fiascoblue03/11/17 08:57 AM
                                                Ryzen fiascojuanrga03/12/17 05:51 AM
                                                  Ryzen fiascoanon03/12/17 08:18 AM
                                                    Ryzen fiascojuanrga03/12/17 09:14 AM
                                                      Ryzen fiascoAlberto03/12/17 10:33 AM
                                                      Ryzen fiascomajord03/12/17 10:26 PM
                                                        Ryzen fiascoMegol03/13/17 04:50 AM
                                                        Ryzen fiascojuanrga03/13/17 10:14 AM
                                                          Ryzen fiascomajord03/14/17 07:51 PM
                                                            Ryzen fiascojuanrga03/15/17 02:51 AM
                                                              Power matters servers, not consumerblue03/16/17 09:22 PM
                                                                Power matters servers, not consumerjuanrga03/18/17 12:32 PM
                                                                  <105W over 13 resultsblue03/18/17 08:02 PM
                                                                    <105W over 13 results (only in your imagination))juanrga03/19/17 06:07 AM
                                                                      you confirm 105W *doh*Blue03/19/17 04:00 PM
                                                                        you confirm 105W *doh* (only in your imagination) (NT)juanrga03/20/17 03:35 AM
                                                  Ryzen fiascoGabriele Svelto03/12/17 01:25 PM
                                                    Ryzen fiascojuanrga03/13/17 10:38 AM
                                                      Ryzen fiascoGabriele Svelto03/13/17 02:54 PM
                                                        Ryzen fiascojuanrga03/14/17 05:05 AM
                                                          Ryzen brings back the fight to PC marketmuziqaz03/14/17 08:09 AM
                                                            Ryzen fiascojuanrga03/15/17 03:56 AM
                                                              Ryzen fiascoBrendan03/15/17 09:59 AM
                                                          Ryzen fiascomajord03/14/17 08:25 PM
                                                            Ryzen fiascojuanrga03/15/17 03:21 AM
                                                              Ryzen fiascomajord03/15/17 06:09 PM
                                                                Ryzen fiascojuanrga03/16/17 04:30 AM
                                                                  Ryzen fiascomajord03/16/17 03:34 PM
                                                                    Ryzen fiascoblue03/16/17 09:28 PM
                                                                    Ryzen fiascojuanrga03/18/17 01:10 PM
                                                                      HPC relative to consumers, not professional/HPCblue03/20/17 12:41 PM
                                                                        HPC relative to consumers, not professional/HPCGabriele Svelto03/20/17 03:08 PM
                                                                          HPC relative to consumers, not professional/HPCMichael S03/20/17 03:26 PM
                                                                            HPC relative to consumers, not professional/HPCGabriele Svelto03/20/17 04:39 PM
                                                                            HPC relative to consumers, not professional/HPCJukka Larja03/21/17 07:53 AM
                                                                        HPC relative to consumers, not professional/HPCKlimax03/21/17 12:33 AM
                                                                          HPC relative to consumers, not professional/HPCDomaldel03/21/17 01:41 AM
                                                                            HPC relative to consumers, not professional/HPCanon03/21/17 11:13 AM
                                                                          HPC relative to consumers, not professional/HPCMichael S03/21/17 02:33 AM
                                                                        HPC relative to consumers, not professional/HPCEmil Briggs03/21/17 11:03 AM
                                                                          HPC relative to consumers, not professional/HPCMichael S03/21/17 11:23 AM
                                                                            HPC relative to consumers, not professional/HPCEmil Briggs03/21/17 11:39 AM
                                                                              HPC relative to consumers, not professional/HPCGabriele Svelto03/23/17 08:10 AM
                                                                                HPC relative to consumers, not professional/HPCEmil Briggs03/23/17 06:30 PM
                                                                                  HPC relative to consumers, not professional/HPCGabriele Svelto03/24/17 03:13 AM
                                                                                    HPC relative to consumers, not professional/HPCIreland03/24/17 03:06 PM
                                                                                  HPC relative to consumers, not professional/HPCAdrian03/24/17 07:16 AM
                                                                                    HPC relative to consumers, not professional/HPCEmil Briggs03/24/17 01:53 PM
                                                                                      HPC relative to consumers, not professional/HPCAdrian03/25/17 03:04 AM
                  Ryzen vs BroadwellE Powerblue03/06/17 04:29 PM
      LinkAlberto03/06/17 06:30 AM
        Link.....sorryAlberto03/06/17 06:32 AM
          Link.....sorryanon03/06/17 08:21 AM
            Link.....sorryAlberto03/06/17 02:11 PM
            Link.....sorryAlberto03/06/17 02:42 PM
              Link.....sorryanon03/06/17 04:06 PM
Reply to this Topic
Name:
Email:
Topic:
Body: No Text
How do you spell green?