Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!

By: Ian Ameline (ian.ameline.delete@this.gmail.elidethis.com), July 11, 2013 3:20 pm
Room: Moderated Discussions
I'd love to see a comparison of spec int. Not rate -- just spec int -- and of those, gcc is probably the most important benchmark. It would be very enlightening to see it compared across A9, A15, Apples's Swift, nVidias'a latest Tegra, Qualcoms's Krait, and Intel's Saltwell.

And for FP, of course SpecFP -- all these dhrystone/whetstone numbers are complete and total meaningless bullshit.

As for using NEON, on iOS, you can depend on it being there. Autodesk Sketchbook mobile for iOS uses NEON -- and actually won't run if it is not there. (I wrote the NEON code in it -- it's almost all fixed point pixel blending / interpolation math)

-- Ian.

Linus Torvalds (torvalds.delete@this.linux-foundation.org) on July 11, 2013 11:20 am wrote:
> Linus Torvalds (torvalds.delete@this.linux-foundation.org) on July 11, 2013 10:57 am wrote:
> >
> > No sane person uses NEON, because NEON isn't available in most ARM implementations.
>
> Side note: this is where virtual machines can help: JIT'ing to whatever is the underlying
> hardware model. At the same time, JITs are particularly bad at things like vectorization
> for anything but the simplest possible case unless the VM itself has some kind of vector
> model. It's just really hard to vectorize things without lots of contextual information.
>
> But for a "native code" benchmark, I still claim that disabling NEON is actually
> the sane thing to do given the current (and near-future) ARM situation.
>
> In contrast, using SSE on x86 makes sense, because it's universally available.
> So the people here screaming "x86 uses SSE, but ARM doesn't use NEON - unfair"
> don't really understand the issues, and are just making braying noises.
>
> None of that makes AnTuTu a better benchmark, though. Microbenchmarks that don't do real work are universally
> crap. Of course, the ARM people shouldn't really complain - they've been using those kinds of pointless
> benchmarks for decades, and continue to do so (google for "dhrystone MIPS" - there are ARM people who
> use that crap still, and Wilco used to quote it religiously not that long ago)
>
> Linus

< Previous Post in ThreadNext Post in Thread >
TopicPosted ByDate
ARM at Computexanon2013/06/03 08:54 AM
  ARM at ComputexExophase2013/06/03 09:31 AM
    ARM at ComputexWilco2013/06/03 10:52 AM
      ARM at ComputexExophase2013/06/03 12:02 PM
        ARM at Computexnone2013/06/03 01:28 PM
          ARM at ComputexAlberto2013/06/04 10:41 AM
            ARM at Computexanon2013/06/04 01:36 PM
              ARM at ComputexWilco2013/06/04 03:56 PM
                ARM at ComputexDavid Kanter2013/06/04 04:51 PM
                  ARM at ComputexNobodyatAll2013/06/04 05:53 PM
                  ARM at Computexanon2013/06/04 06:53 PM
        ARM at ComputexWilco2013/06/03 01:47 PM
    ARM at Computexanon2013/06/04 04:03 AM
      ARM at ComputexDavid Kanter2013/06/04 08:16 AM
      ARM at ComputexExophase2013/06/04 10:36 AM
        ARM at ComputexWilco2013/06/04 04:09 PM
          ARM at ComputexNobodyatAll2013/06/04 04:23 PM
          ARM at ComputexDavid Kanter2013/06/04 05:00 PM
            ARM at Computexnone2013/06/05 05:26 AM
              ARM at Computexanon2013/06/05 07:19 AM
              ARM at Computexaaron spink2013/06/05 03:04 PM
                Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Jason2013/06/07 01:56 PM
                  Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!John2013/06/08 06:28 AM
                    Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Kevin G2013/06/08 02:18 PM
                      Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!David Kanter2013/06/08 08:43 PM
                      Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!tarlinian2013/06/09 02:00 PM
                        Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!none2013/06/09 03:11 PM
                          Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!none2013/07/10 11:46 AM
                            Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Wilco2013/07/10 07:59 PM
                              Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Klimax2013/07/10 10:03 PM
                                Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!anon2013/07/10 10:29 PM
                                  Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Klimax2013/07/10 11:30 PM
                                    Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Wilco2013/07/11 01:04 AM
                                      Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Klimax2013/07/11 03:10 AM
                                        Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!anon2013/07/11 04:10 AM
                                        Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Wilco2013/07/11 04:43 AM
                                        Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Steve2013/07/14 08:10 PM
                                          Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Klimax2013/07/14 10:55 PM
                                          Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!bakaneko2013/07/15 02:03 AM
                                            Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!anon2013/07/16 01:07 AM
                                              Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!bakaneko2013/07/16 06:25 AM
                                                Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!none2013/07/16 06:34 AM
                                                Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Exophase2013/07/16 10:34 AM
                                                  Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!bakaneko2013/07/18 02:24 PM
                                                    Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!none2013/07/18 03:26 PM
                                    Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!anon2013/07/11 02:50 AM
                                      Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Klimax2013/07/11 11:25 PM
                                        Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!anon2013/07/11 11:45 PM
                                          Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Klimax2013/07/12 12:10 AM
                                            Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!anon2013/07/12 01:52 AM
                                    Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Gabriele Svelto2013/07/11 04:20 AM
                                      Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Klimax2013/07/11 11:51 PM
                                Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!bakaneko2013/07/11 12:02 AM
                                  Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Klimax2013/07/11 12:28 AM
                                    Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!none2013/07/11 01:49 AM
                                      Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Klimax2013/07/11 03:00 AM
                                        Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Klimax2013/07/11 03:02 AM
                                        Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!none2013/07/11 04:44 AM
                                          Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Michael S2013/07/11 05:33 AM
                                            Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!none2013/07/11 05:58 AM
                                              Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!none2013/07/11 05:59 AM
                                              Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Wilco2013/07/11 07:40 AM
                                                Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Michael S2013/07/11 08:34 AM
                                                  Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!none2013/07/11 08:50 AM
                                              Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Michael S2013/07/11 09:02 AM
                                          Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Klimax2013/07/11 10:11 PM
                                      Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Michael S2013/07/11 04:12 AM
                                        Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!none2013/07/11 04:51 AM
                                          Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Wilco2013/07/11 05:03 AM
                                            Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!none2013/07/11 05:12 AM
                                              Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Wilco2013/07/11 07:26 AM
                                                Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!none2013/07/11 08:29 AM
                                                Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Wilco2013/07/12 04:08 AM
                                                  Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Michael S2013/07/12 04:25 AM
                                              Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Klimax2013/07/11 11:55 PM
                                                Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Megol2013/07/13 07:20 AM
                                    Java/Dalvik benchmarksbakaneko2013/07/11 02:26 AM
                                  Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Linus Torvalds2013/07/11 10:57 AM
                                    Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Linus Torvalds2013/07/11 11:20 AM
                                      Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Ian Ameline2013/07/11 03:20 PM
                                      Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Sylvain Collange2013/07/12 02:29 AM
                                        Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Wilco2013/07/12 03:51 AM
                                          Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Sylvain Collange2013/07/12 06:00 AM
                                      Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!bakaneko2013/07/12 03:28 AM
                                        Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Linus Torvalds2013/07/12 09:11 AM
                                          Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!bakaneko2013/07/12 10:12 AM
                                          Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!2013/07/12 10:48 AM
                                            Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!Linus Torvalds2013/07/12 11:14 AM
                                              JIT2013/07/13 05:50 AM
                                                How'd you get this flower symbol as your user name ?anon2013/07/13 09:20 AM
                                                  How'd you get this flower symbol as your user name ?Doug S Ꭳ❂〄☢⚓♜☎♬⚄☠2013/07/13 10:12 AM
                                                JITx2013/07/15 06:43 AM
                                    Not reallyAnon2013/07/11 11:21 AM
                                    consistency, pleaseMichael S2013/07/11 11:22 AM
                                      consistency, pleaseLinus Torvalds2013/07/11 11:52 AM
                                        consistency, pleaseMichael S2013/07/11 02:43 PM
                                          consistency, pleaseLinus Torvalds2013/07/11 03:12 PM
                                            consistency, pleaseMark Roulo2013/07/11 03:54 PM
                                              the discussion was about absence of AVX in Silvermont (NT)Michael S2013/07/11 03:59 PM
                                                the discussion was about absence of AVX in SilvermontMark Roulo2013/07/11 04:19 PM
                                                  the discussion was about absence of AVX in SilvermontLinus Torvalds2013/07/12 09:16 AM
                                                    Thank youMark Roulo2013/07/12 09:58 AM
                                                    the discussion was about absence of AVX in Silvermontanon2013/07/12 10:10 AM
                                                      Not really (again)Anon2013/07/12 10:26 AM
                                                        Not really (again)anon2013/07/12 05:40 PM
                                                    the discussion was about absence of AVX in SilvermontLinus Torvalds2013/07/12 10:31 AM
                                                      you are wrong at about 100% of you saidMichael S2013/07/13 11:22 AM
                                                        you are wrong at about 100% of you saidLinus Torvalds2013/07/13 12:08 PM
                                                          you are wrong at about 100% of you saidMichael S2013/07/13 01:13 PM
                                                            you are wrong at about 100% of you saidLinus Torvalds2013/07/13 02:11 PM
                                                            you are wrong at about 100% of you saidvvid2013/07/13 03:20 PM
                                                              you are wrong at about 100% of you saidMichael S2013/07/14 01:38 AM
                                    Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!anon2013/07/11 06:41 PM
                                    Saltwell Outperforming A15...With Less Power!!!bakaneko2013/07/12 03:22 AM
                  Round 2: Baytrail benchmark (yes Antutu!) crushes Snapdragon 800.sammy2013/07/12 11:28 AM
                    Round 2: AnTuTu scores drop dramatically for AtomWilco2013/07/12 11:59 AM
                      Round 2: AnTuTu scores drop dramatically for AtomSteve2013/07/14 08:16 PM
                        Round 2: AnTuTu scores drop dramatically for AtomKlimax2013/07/14 10:59 PM
                        Round 2: AnTuTu scores drop dramatically for AtomDavid Kanter2013/07/15 01:57 PM
                          Intel is cheating AnTuTuWilco2013/07/15 03:43 PM
                            Intel is cheating AnTuTubakaneko2013/07/15 07:47 PM
                              Intel is cheating AnTuTuLinus Torvalds2013/07/15 08:45 PM
                                Intel is cheating AnTuTubakaneko2013/07/16 02:42 AM
                                  Intel is cheating AnTuTuWilco2013/07/16 03:47 AM
                                    Intel is cheating AnTuTubakaneko2013/07/16 05:50 AM
                                      Intel is cheating AnTuTuWilco2013/07/17 03:33 PM
                                        Intel is cheating AnTuTuKlimax2013/07/17 11:29 PM
                                          Intel is cheating AnTuTunone2013/07/17 11:35 PM
                                            Intel is cheating AnTuTuKlimax2013/07/18 01:41 AM
                                              Intel is cheating AnTuTuanon2013/07/18 02:10 AM
                                                Intel is cheating AnTuTuMichael S2013/07/18 03:39 AM
                                                Intel is cheating AnTuTuWilco2013/07/18 04:07 AM
                                                  Intel is cheating AnTuTunone2013/07/18 04:15 AM
                                                    Intel is cheating AnTuTuWilco2013/07/18 05:18 AM
                                                    Intel is cheating AnTuTuMichael S2013/07/18 06:44 AM
                                                      Intel is cheating AnTuTunone2013/07/18 07:47 AM
                                                        strict aliasingMichael S2013/07/18 08:10 AM
                                                          strict aliasing rules have existed since C89 (NT)Ricardo B2013/07/18 05:28 PM
                                                  Intel is cheating AnTuTuKlimax2013/07/18 11:30 AM
                                                Intel is cheating AnTuTuKlimax2013/07/18 11:39 AM
                                                  Intel is cheating AnTuTuanon2013/07/18 12:05 PM
                                                    Intel is cheating AnTuTuKlimax2013/07/20 12:05 AM
                                                      Intel is cheating AnTuTunone2013/07/20 02:50 AM
                                                  Intel is cheating AnTuTunone2013/07/18 12:38 PM
                                                    Intel is cheating AnTuTuKlimax2013/07/19 11:57 PM
                                  Intel is cheating AnTuTuLinus Torvalds2013/07/16 12:32 PM
                                Intel is cheating AnTuTu2013/07/16 03:16 AM
                                  Intel is cheating AnTuTubakaneko2013/07/16 04:55 AM
                                    Intel is cheating AnTuTuWilco2013/07/17 03:46 PM
                                      Intel is cheating AnTuTubakaneko2013/07/18 02:05 PM
                                      Intel is cheating AnTuTuDavid Kanter2013/07/19 02:31 AM
                          Round 2: AnTuTu scores drop dramatically for Atomanon2013/07/15 04:43 PM
                            Round 2: AnTuTu scores drop dramatically for Atomnone2013/07/16 12:15 AM
                          Round 2: AnTuTu scores drop dramatically for AtomGroo2013/07/16 07:35 AM
        ARM at Computexanon2013/06/04 10:43 PM
Reply to this Topic
Name:
Email:
Topic:
Body: No Text
How do you spell avocado?