Knights Landing CPU Speculation

Article: Knights Landing CPU Speculation
By: Michael S (already5chosen.delete@this.yahoo.com), November 27, 2013 2:53 am
Room: Moderated Discussions
Chung Leong (cleong.delete@this.cal.berkeley.edu) on November 27, 2013 2:28 am wrote:
> Amiba Gelos (b98202036.delete@this.ntu.edu.tw) on November 19, 2013 8:36 pm wrote:
> > First, noticed that the scalar computing capacity of Larrabee is already 4 times
> > of GCN's, not to mention Fermi/Kepler which rely on CPU to execute every "less-paralleled"
> > code, further improvement over Larrabee core seems to be unnecessary.
>
> Perhaps Intel's aim is to enable the Larrabee to run traditional server applications more effectively, so
> that it can function sort of like Sun's Niagara? It makes sense from the point of view of the cloud computing
> business. During business hours, you devote your machines to running things like MySQL and Apache. Then at
> night, you lease them to folks who do lots of number crunching. To that end, the core needs to have at least
> OoOE. A P6 derived core running at 2GHz+ (when the vector units are idle) would do the trick.

But for "pure throughput" commercial workloads a migration from small 4-way SMT cores to bigger non-SMT cores is counter-productive even when the later have 3-times higher single-thread performance.

If rumors about 72 Silvermont-derived cores running at 2.67 GHz are true, then the resulting chip will have no advantages over existing SPARC-T5 in commercial loads, neither in single-thread speed, nor in throughput (there may be ~50% advantage on embarrassingly parallel workloads with very high L2 hit rates, but not on anything even remotely real-world) nor in TDP. But it will be at serious disadvantage in memory capacity and SMP scalability.
< Previous Post in ThreadNext Post in Thread >
TopicPosted ByDate
Knights Landing CPU SpeculationDavid Kanter2013/11/18 02:03 AM
  Knights Landing CPU Speculationnone2013/11/18 02:59 AM
    Knights Landing CPU SpeculationPatrick Chase2013/11/23 03:18 PM
      Knights Landing CPU Speculation2013/11/26 01:20 AM
        Over 2,000 mm^2 of eDRAM???Mark Roulo2013/11/26 09:28 AM
          Over 2,000 mm^2 of eDRAM???David Kanter2013/11/26 11:09 AM
          Over 2,000 mm^2 of eDRAM???Eric Bron2013/11/26 11:21 AM
            Over 2,000 mm^2 of eDRAM???tarlinian2013/11/26 11:50 AM
              Over 2,000 mm^2 of eDRAM???Eric Bron2013/11/26 01:07 PM
                Over 2,000 mm^2 of eDRAM???Eric Bron2013/11/26 01:09 PM
                Over 2,000 mm^2 of eDRAM???aaron spink2013/11/26 03:03 PM
                  Over 2,000 mm^2 of eDRAM???Eric Bron2013/11/26 11:42 PM
                    Over 2,000 mm^2 of eDRAM???aaron spink2013/11/27 10:31 AM
              Over 2,000 mm^2 of eDRAM???David Kanter2013/11/26 04:25 PM
                Over 2,000 mm^2 of eDRAM???tarlinian2013/11/26 07:01 PM
          Over 2,000 mm^2 of eDRAM???Eric2013/11/27 02:54 AM
            eDRAM is DRAM in a logic-oriented processPaul A. Clayton2013/11/27 07:10 AM
  Knights Landing CPU SpeculationJames2013/11/18 05:26 AM
    Knights Landing CPU SpeculationMichael S2013/11/18 02:57 PM
      Knights Landing CPU SpeculationUrban Novak2013/11/19 12:49 AM
        Knights Landing CPU Speculationnone2013/11/19 01:19 AM
          Knights Landing CPU SpeculationEric2013/11/19 07:48 PM
            Total GPGPU/Xeon Phi market maybe ~ $500M/year ...Mark Roulo2013/11/20 10:35 AM
      Knights Landing CPU SpeculationWes Felter2013/11/19 12:06 PM
        Knights Landing CPU SpeculationMichael S2013/11/19 12:49 PM
  Knights Landing CPU SpeculationEric2013/11/18 12:17 PM
    Knights Landing CPU SpeculationDaniel2013/11/19 02:28 AM
      Knights Landing CPU SpeculationEric2013/11/19 07:36 PM
      HPC guys score FLOPS non-obviouslyMark Roulo2013/11/20 10:43 AM
        3-TFlops-DGEMMMichael S2013/11/20 10:59 AM
          3-TFlops-DGEMMMark Roulo2013/11/20 12:22 PM
            3-TFlops-DGEMMDaniel2013/11/20 01:04 PM
              3-TFlops-DGEMMEric2013/11/21 01:28 AM
                3-TFlops-DGEMMMichael S2013/11/21 05:48 AM
                  3-TFlops-DGEMMRecessionCone2013/11/21 11:13 AM
                    3-TFlops-DGEMMMichael S2013/11/21 02:34 PM
                  3-TFlops-DGEMMEric2013/11/22 02:10 AM
                    3-TFlops-DGEMMMichael S2013/11/22 04:41 AM
                    A (not very sensible) alternative: FMADD + FADDPaul A. Clayton2013/11/22 08:19 AM
                  3-TFlops-DGEMMSylvain Collange2013/11/24 02:37 AM
                    3-TFlops-DGEMMMichael S2013/11/24 06:06 AM
                      3-TFlops-DGEMMSylvain Collange2013/11/24 09:28 AM
        HPC guys score FLOPS non-obviouslyPatrick Chase2013/11/23 02:58 PM
  Knights Landing CPU SpeculationPaul Caheny2013/11/18 01:25 PM
    Knights Landing CPU SpeculationKonrad Schwarz2013/11/19 12:24 AM
  Knights Landing CPU SpeculationAmiba Gelos2013/11/19 07:36 PM
    Knights Landing CPU SpeculationDavid Kanter2013/11/20 09:52 AM
    Knights Landing CPU SpeculationLinus Torvalds2013/11/21 02:12 PM
      Knights Landing CPU SpeculationAmiba Gelos2013/11/21 05:14 PM
      Knights Landing CPU SpeculationPatrick Chase2013/11/23 03:33 PM
        Knights Landing CPU SpeculationLinus Torvalds2013/11/25 11:29 AM
          Knights Landing CPU SpeculationLinus Torvalds2013/11/25 12:05 PM
          Knights Landing CPU SpeculationPatrick Chase2013/11/25 12:22 PM
            Knights Landing CPU SpeculationLinus Torvalds2013/11/26 10:11 AM
          Knights Landing CPU SpeculationEric2013/11/26 03:05 AM
            Knights Landing CPU SpeculationEric2013/11/26 03:15 AM
            Knights Landing CPU Speculationnone2013/11/26 03:33 AM
              Knights Landing CPU SpeculationEric2013/11/26 06:30 PM
                Knights Landing CPU SpeculationEric2013/11/26 06:34 PM
                  What is MCDRAM?anon2013/11/26 08:58 PM
                    What is MCDRAM?none2013/11/27 01:00 AM
                      What is MCDRAM?Klimax2013/11/27 02:19 AM
                  Knights Landing CPU SpeculationKlimax2013/11/26 11:06 PM
                Knights Landing CPU SpeculationKlimax2013/11/26 11:05 PM
            Knights Landing CPU Speculationanon2013/11/26 05:53 AM
              Knights Landing CPU Speculationnone2013/11/26 06:20 AM
                Knights Landing CPU SpeculationMichael S2013/11/26 08:06 AM
                  Knights Landing CPU Speculationnone2013/11/26 09:18 AM
                    Knights Landing CPU SpeculationEric Bron2013/11/26 01:21 PM
                      Knights Landing CPU SpeculationEric Bron2013/11/26 01:27 PM
                        Knights Landing CPU Speculationnone2013/11/26 02:26 PM
                    Knights Landing CPU Speculationanon2013/11/26 05:42 PM
                      Knights Landing CPU Speculationnone2013/11/27 01:08 AM
                        Knights Landing CPU Speculationanon2013/11/27 01:50 AM
                          Knights Landing CPU Speculationnone2013/11/27 01:58 AM
                      Knights Landing CPU SpeculationMichael S2013/11/27 01:25 AM
                        Knights Landing CPU Speculationanon2013/11/27 02:32 AM
                          Knights Landing CPU SpeculationMichael S2013/11/27 03:08 AM
    Knights Landing CPU SpeculationChung Leong2013/11/27 01:28 AM
      Knights Landing CPU SpeculationMichael S2013/11/27 02:53 AM
        Knights Landing CPU SpeculationChung Leong2013/11/27 01:03 PM
  BiG.LiTTLe for KNL?Jeff K2013/11/22 06:17 AM
    BiG.LiTTLe for KNL?Patrick Chase2013/11/23 02:54 PM
      BiG.LiTTLe for KNL?Patrick Chase2013/11/23 03:01 PM
  Transactional memoryPatrick Chase2013/11/23 02:37 PM
    Transactional memoryBhima2013/11/25 07:01 AM
      Transactional memoryPatrick Chase2013/11/25 11:52 AM
  Knights Landing CPU SpeculationDaniel2013/11/25 02:17 AM
    Knights Landing CPU SpeculationKlimax2013/11/25 03:12 AM
    Knights Landing CPU Speculationnone2013/11/25 04:05 AM
      Knights Landing CPU SpeculationKlimax2013/11/25 04:45 AM
        Knights Landing CPU Speculationnone2013/11/25 04:55 AM
          Knights Landing CPU Speculationgmb2013/11/25 07:21 AM
Reply to this Topic
Name:
Email:
Topic:
Body: No Text
How do you spell green?