slit vs unified

By: dmcq (, February 11, 2015 5:44 am
Room: Moderated Discussions
Michael S ( on February 10, 2015 2:57 pm wrote:
> Jouni Osmala ( on February 10, 2015 12:24 pm wrote:
> > > > I'd don't know what changed within ARM application processor
> > > > group, but recently they have very high success
> > > > rate: A7, A12, A53, A17 are all pretty good.
> > >
> > > Focus on incremental improvement maybe? A8, A9 and A15 were all big jumps with significantly different
> > > micro-architectures than their predecessors. All of the ones you listed on the other hand have evolved
> > > from previous cores. They have better branch prediction, tighter coupling of the L1/L2 caches and
> > > other improvements which do not significantly affect the execution core yet provide very significant
> > > benefits, and especially so in integer codes. Most of those improvements can also be shared between
> > > the cores so that might also have helped out in focusing development efforts.
> >
> > Those small tweaks matter a lot. The difference between nehalem and cortex A15 is mostly in
> > those tweaks. Cortex has wider execution stage, but nehalem is more tweaked and has better memory
> > subsystem and maybe better branch predictor,and fetches more instructions per cycle. By wider
> > core I mean nehalem's 3 compute pipelines vs cortex 6 compute pipelines, and both have same
> > number of loads/stores per cycle. A15 scheduler contains more operations than nehalems.
> You can't compare OoO cores based on unified scheduler (Nehalem) with cores based on split scheduler
> (Cortex-A15) in such simplistic manner. If you want to compare CA15 with x86, it would make much
> more sense to compare to another split-scheduler design like AMD K8. K8 can dispatch up to 9 uOPs
> per clock, one more than CA15, but real difference in in dispatch width is even bigger in favor
> of K8 is even bigger, because its dispatch ports are more universal. Most importantly, K8 capable
> to dispatch up to 3 integer ALU/shift instructions per clock (matching fat Intel cores by this metric)
> or resolve to 3 branches while CA15 can only issue 2 integer ALU/shift instructions per clock and
> resolve 1 branch. So, both cores feature split schedulers, but K8 is "less split".
> For reference, CA15 OoO schedulers (clusters, in ARM terms) and dispatch rates per scheduler:
> 1. Simple ALU/shift, 2
> 2. Branch, 1
> 3. Neon/FPU, 2
> 4. Multiply, 1 (also handles integer divide)
> 5. LSU, 2, 1 load, 1 store
> BTW, it's still not clear to me where store data is coming from. Does store unit has 3 read ports (2 for address
> and one for data) into register file and result queue or it somehow steals read port from another EU
> Also, on non-related note, when speaking about width you can't totally ignore in-order
> front end and in-order retirement parts of the core, both of each on CA15 (3 simple
> uOps) are narrower then on both Nehalem (4 fused uOps) and K8 (3 macro-ops).

Well for the ARM A15 a slide says the store operations are issued in order and issue when the address registers are available - not the data. So I guess they are really just generating the address and the actual store is done separately.
< Previous Post in ThreadNext Post in Thread >
TopicPosted ByDate
ARM announces A72Maynard Handley2015/02/03 11:36 AM
  ARM announces A72anon2015/02/03 12:53 PM
    ARM announces A72Hugo D√©charnes2015/02/03 01:20 PM
      ARM announces A72juanrga2015/02/03 04:15 PM
        ARM announces A72Wilco2015/02/04 12:58 AM
          ARM announces A72Eric Bron2015/02/04 01:48 AM
            ARM announces A72none2015/02/04 02:24 AM
              ARM announces A72Eric Bron2015/02/04 02:42 AM
                ARM announces A72Exophase2015/02/04 07:01 AM
                  ARM announces A72Anon2015/02/04 07:35 AM
                    ARM announces A72Exophase2015/02/04 07:58 AM
                      ARM announces A72Groo2015/02/04 09:24 AM
                ARM Marketing, BS up to my earsDavid Kanter2015/02/04 10:51 AM
                  ARM Marketing, BS up to my earsMaynard Handley2015/02/04 01:59 PM
                    ARM Marketing, BS up to my earsDavid Kanter2015/02/04 02:21 PM
                  ARM Marketing, BS up to my earsGroo2015/02/04 02:30 PM
          ARM announces A72juanrga2015/02/04 04:23 AM
            ARM announces A72Wilco2015/02/04 03:01 PM
              ARM announces A72juanrga2015/02/04 04:06 PM
        ARM announces A72Anon2015/02/04 01:28 AM
          ARM announces A72juanrga2015/02/04 04:31 AM
            ARM announces A72Aaron Spink2015/02/04 06:49 AM
      ARM announces A72Ronald Maas2015/02/03 07:23 PM
        ARM announces A72Seni2015/02/04 12:19 AM
          ARM announces A72Maynard Handley2015/02/04 10:42 AM
            ARM announces A72Seni2015/02/04 12:33 PM
              ARM announces A72dmcq2015/02/04 12:57 PM
            ARM announces A72Ronald Maas2015/02/04 06:42 PM
        ARM announces A72anon2015/02/04 05:19 AM
          ARM announces A72Exophase2015/02/04 07:31 AM
            ARM announces A72David Kanter2015/02/04 10:25 AM
              ARM announces A72Exophase2015/02/04 01:33 PM
                ARM announces A72anon2015/02/04 10:27 PM
                  ARM announces A72 (fixed format)anon2015/02/04 10:29 PM
                  ARM announces A72Exophase2015/02/04 11:11 PM
                    ARM announces A72anon2015/02/05 12:02 AM
            ARM announces A72anon2015/02/04 05:57 PM
  ARM announces A72Wilco2015/02/03 01:39 PM
    ARM announces A72Maynard Handley2015/02/03 02:13 PM
      ARM announces A72anon2015/02/03 02:29 PM
      ARM announces A72Wilco2015/02/03 02:44 PM
    ARM announces A72David Kanter2015/02/04 09:56 AM
      ARM announces A72Peter Greenhalgh2015/02/04 10:56 AM
        ARM announces A72Aaron Spink2015/02/04 11:59 AM
          ARM announces A72Alberto2015/02/07 10:22 AM
            ARM announces A72Exophase2015/02/07 10:47 AM
              ARM announces A72Alberto2015/02/07 12:44 PM
                ARM announces A72Exophase2015/02/07 02:35 PM
                  ARM announces A72Alberto2015/02/08 01:09 AM
                    ARM announces A72Exophase2015/02/08 11:05 AM
              ARM announces A72David Kanter2015/02/08 12:39 AM
                ARM announces A72dmcq2015/02/08 04:14 AM
                  ARM announces A72Michael S2015/02/08 04:38 AM
                    ARM announces A72Gabriele Svelto2015/02/10 05:11 AM
                      ARM announces A72Jouni Osmala2015/02/10 11:24 AM
                        slit vs unifiedMichael S2015/02/10 01:57 PM
                          slit vs unifieddmcq2015/02/11 05:44 AM
                  ARM announces A72Doug S2015/02/08 09:00 AM
                ARM announces A72Exophase2015/02/08 10:57 AM
        ARM announces A72dmcq2015/02/04 01:10 PM
        ARM announces A72David Kanter2015/02/04 02:28 PM
      ARM announces A72Wilco2015/02/04 01:59 PM
        ARM announces A72Aaron Spink2015/02/04 09:31 PM
        Intel 32nm vs 14 nmMichael S2015/02/05 01:03 AM
          Intel 32nm vs 14 nmWilco2015/02/05 02:27 AM
            Intel 32nm vs 14 nmDavid Kanter2015/02/05 09:05 AM
              Intel 32nm vs 14 nmcarop2015/02/05 11:12 AM
                Normalize to drawn or effective width?David Kanter2015/02/05 11:45 AM
                  Normalize to drawn or effective width?carop2015/02/05 02:40 PM
                    Normalize to drawn or effective width?David Kanter2015/02/06 12:44 PM
Reply to this Topic
Body: No Text
How do you spell tangerine? ūüćä