Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zen

By: Jukka Larja (roskakori2006.delete@this.gmail.com), October 5, 2015 9:15 am
Room: Moderated Discussions
Contrarian (Whatever.delete@this.hotmail.com) on October 4, 2015 11:53 am wrote:

> Alright, we know AVX2 is easy to implement, but is AVX2 a waste of die space?
>
> Do games use AVX2 and for those games that do use AVX2 do they get a significant speed up?

No, and no, though that depends on how you define significant.

I'm sure some engines and middleware implement AVX2 paths, but the bottom line is that you can't expect to have AVX2 instructions available (you can expect SSE2, since it's part of x86-64, but that's about it). Most games still ship only 32 bit binaries, just to give some idea about where we stand today.

You want your game to run on lowish GHz, non-AVX2 dual cores, yet enthusiasts will have quad-cores at 3+ GHz. AVX2 just isn't all that important, since it doesn't bring minimum requirements down and you already get very near the top with quite affortable processor. Using only 40 % of CPU instead of 50 % isn't very useful. And while 4 float wide SSE and AVX can be used to speed up normal vector3 calculations (somewhat), 8 wide AVX2 often requires you to rethink your code. Not something you want to do to speed up some marginal cases.

-JLarja
< Previous Post in ThreadNext Post in Thread >
TopicPosted ByDate
Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenjuanrga2015/10/03 04:48 AM
  Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenHeikki Kultala2015/10/03 08:01 AM
    Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenitsmydamnation2015/10/03 03:47 PM
      Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenAnders2015/10/03 11:04 PM
        Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenContrarian2015/10/04 11:53 AM
          Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenJukka Larja2015/10/05 09:15 AM
            Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenmpx2015/10/05 09:37 AM
              Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenContrarian2015/10/25 12:25 PM
                Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenitsmydamnation2015/10/26 01:49 AM
                Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenjuanrga2015/10/29 02:16 AM
                  Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenanon2015/10/30 06:54 AM
                    Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenjuanrga2015/10/30 10:37 AM
                    POWER8 load/store unitsGabriele Svelto2015/10/30 06:34 PM
                Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenlurker2015/10/29 03:12 PM
                  Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenDavid Kanter2015/10/30 12:06 AM
                    Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenlurker2015/10/30 02:39 AM
                      Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenGabriele Svelto2015/10/30 03:14 AM
                        Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenlurker2015/10/30 03:41 AM
                      Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zendmcq2015/10/30 05:12 AM
                        Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenlurker2015/10/30 05:56 AM
                          Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zendmcq2015/10/30 06:09 AM
                            Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zennone2015/10/30 06:16 AM
                          Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenDavid Kanter2015/10/30 08:16 AM
                            Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenlurker2015/10/30 08:44 AM
                          Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenjuanrga2015/10/30 01:00 PM
                            AVX and 128-bit FPUs in Zen(Re:Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zen)Heikki Kultala2015/10/30 03:45 PM
                              AVX and 128-bit FPUs in Zen(Re:Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zen)juanrga2015/10/31 06:20 AM
                                AVX and 128-bit FPUs in Zen(Re:Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zen)Heikki Kultala2015/10/31 02:19 PM
                                  AVX and 128-bit FPUs in Zen(Re:Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zen)juanrga2015/11/01 07:41 AM
                                    AVX and 128-bit FPUs in Zen(Re:Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zen)Anne O. Nymous2015/11/01 09:39 AM
                                AVX and 128-bit FPUs in Zen(Re:Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zen)Matthias Waldhauer2015/11/02 01:26 PM
                                  AVX and 128-bit FPUs in Zen(Re:Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zen)juanrga2015/11/03 03:42 AM
                            Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenMatthias Waldhauer2015/11/02 11:39 AM
                        Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenbakaneko2015/10/31 07:28 AM
                          Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zendmcq2015/10/31 08:19 AM
                            Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenJukka Larja2015/10/31 09:21 AM
                            Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenbakaneko2015/10/31 10:23 AM
                              Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zendmcq2015/10/31 04:12 PM
                                Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenbakaneko2015/10/31 05:25 PM
                                  Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zendmcq2015/11/01 07:36 AM
                                    Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenbakaneko2015/11/01 10:11 AM
                                      Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zendmcq2015/11/01 10:27 AM
                                        Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenbakaneko2015/11/01 03:35 PM
                                          Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zendmcq2015/11/01 04:52 PM
                                            Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenbakaneko2015/11/03 03:17 AM
                                              Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zendmcq2015/11/03 04:17 AM
                  Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenjuanrga2015/10/30 12:43 PM
                    Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenlurker2015/10/30 02:09 PM
                      Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenjuanrga2015/10/31 06:58 AM
                        Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenlurker2015/10/31 08:07 AM
                          Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenjuanrga2015/10/31 12:50 PM
                            Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenPoindexter2015/10/31 02:47 PM
                              Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenlurker2015/10/31 04:06 PM
                                Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenPoindexter2015/10/31 05:37 PM
                                  Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenlurker2015/11/01 03:46 AM
                                  Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenjuanrga2015/11/01 08:16 AM
                                    Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenMaynard Handley2015/11/01 06:33 PM
                                      Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenjuanrga2015/11/02 05:06 AM
                                        Zen transistor countHeikki Kultala2015/11/04 01:30 AM
                                          Zen transistor countjuanrga2015/11/05 05:34 AM
                                    Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenSymmetry2015/11/02 06:56 AM
                                      Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenDavid Hess2015/11/02 07:16 AM
                                      Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zennobody2015/11/02 08:19 AM
                                        Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenJukka Larja2015/11/02 09:34 PM
                                          Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zennobody2015/11/03 01:35 AM
                                            Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenJukka Larja2015/11/03 02:41 AM
                                              Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zennobody2015/11/03 05:10 AM
                                                Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenJukka Larja2015/11/04 02:52 AM
                                            Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenKlimax2015/11/03 02:47 AM
                                              Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zennobody2015/11/03 04:19 AM
                                                Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenKlimax2015/11/03 12:09 PM
                                          Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenBanana_Comedown2015/11/04 11:17 AM
                                            Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenJukka Larja2015/11/05 03:51 AM
                                              Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenBanana_Comedown2015/11/05 01:23 PM
                                      Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenjuanrga2015/11/03 04:13 AM
                                Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zennobody2015/10/31 08:16 PM
                                  Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenlurker2015/11/01 03:48 AM
                                    Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zensylt2015/11/01 04:07 AM
                                    Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zennobody2015/11/01 11:49 AM
                                  Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenmd2015/11/01 01:06 PM
                                    Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenblu2015/11/01 01:59 PM
                                      Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenjuanrga2015/11/02 05:10 AM
                              Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenjuanrga2015/11/01 07:00 AM
                                Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenPoindexter2015/11/01 09:25 AM
                                  Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenjuanrga2015/11/02 04:47 AM
                                    Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenPoindexter2015/11/02 05:39 AM
                                      Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenjuanrga2015/11/02 01:26 PM
                                        Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenDan Downs2015/11/02 03:12 PM
                                          Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenjuanrga2015/11/03 03:51 AM
                            Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenlurker2015/10/31 03:57 PM
                              Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenjuanrga2015/11/01 07:26 AM
                                Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenHeikki Kultala2015/11/01 09:57 AM
                                  Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenMaynard Handley2015/11/01 06:39 PM
                              Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenUngo2015/11/01 02:05 PM
                  Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenquzhujian2015/10/31 10:39 AM
                  Some 'reverse-engineering' of ZenPoindexter2015/11/04 06:10 AM
                    Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zenlurker2015/11/05 01:54 PM
                      Some 'reverse-engineering' of Zennobody2015/11/05 03:28 PM
                      The sad status of tech mediajuanrga2015/11/06 05:19 AM
                        The sad status of tech mediaJoel2015/11/06 06:45 PM
                        The sad status of tech mediaMatthias Waldhauer2015/11/07 03:12 PM
                          The sad status of tech mediaJoel2015/11/07 05:40 PM
Reply to this Topic
Name:
Email:
Topic:
Body: No Text
How do you spell avocado?