[side topic] personal supercomputer (Threadripper 32 core review)

By: hobold (hobold.delete@this.vectorizer.org), August 16, 2018 4:47 am
Room: Moderated Discussions
Full disclosure: I got a 1950x based machine last autumn/fall, and am something of an AMD fanboy since.

Linus Torvalds (torvalds.delete@this.linux-foundation.org) on August 13, 2018 3:48 pm wrote:

[...]
> I'm seriously considering
> upgrading to an AMD system, and the new threadrippers would really fit my load.
>
> During the merge window (like now), I spend a fair amount of time double-checking
> my merges by doing builds before pushing out, and my old i7-6700K is showing
> its age, with the kernel having grown, and meltdown slowing things down.
>

My lens was through rendering algorithms / image synthesis. From that point of view it is IMHO clearly visible that the new 32 core model is seriously starved for memory bandwidth.

"Old style" renderers like PoV-Ray scale very well. Textures are procedural, and secondary rays are being shot in fairly low number, with quite a bit of locality. Memory bandwidth or latency is not much of a problem. Performance gain from 16 to 32 cores is somewhere around 70%.

Blender, in contrast, is a contemporary production quality renderer, but usually spares the effort of a full simulation of light physics. Textures are photogrammetric maps, and some effects may spawn many secondary rays. Blender still scales from 16 to 32 cores, but you gain maybe 30% to 40%.

Very modern physically based path tracers randomly sample all of the scene with little locality, and also use high resolution high precision textures. Scaling from 16 to 32 cores can yield as little as 15% to 20% speedup.

So the 32 core model is not an upgrade I would consider, even if I could spare such money on a whim.

> My main worry is noise. I'm not sure I want to deal with the blower required for a 180W+ CPU.
>

I can attest that Noctua's U14S tower cooler keeps the 1950x under 60 degree Celsius in a well ventilated case. It's not silent, but quiet enough that I can fall asleep in that same room. That cooler is an overpriced, overengineered marvel of perfectionism - I love it! :-)
< Previous Post in ThreadNext Post in Thread >
TopicPosted ByDate
Threadripper 32 core reviewPer Hesselgren2018/08/13 08:50 AM
  Threadripper 32 core reviewwumpus2018/08/13 09:32 AM
    Threadripper 32 core reviewLinus Torvalds2018/08/13 02:12 PM
      Threadripper 32 core reviewpgerassi2018/08/13 03:16 PM
        Threadripper 32 core reviewLinus Torvalds2018/08/13 03:48 PM
          Less Power Hungry Part?Passing Through2018/08/13 04:19 PM
          Threadripper 32 core reviewGroo2018/08/13 04:50 PM
            Threadripper 32 core reviewPassing Through2018/08/14 12:45 PM
          Threadripper 32 core reviewpgerassi2018/08/13 06:41 PM
          Threadripper 32 core reviewjuanrga2018/08/14 04:44 AM
            Threadripper 32 core reviewLinus Torvalds2018/08/14 09:37 AM
              Threadripper 32 core reviewjuanrga2018/08/14 11:18 AM
                Threadripper 32 core reviewjuanrga2018/08/16 02:16 AM
          Threadripper 32 core reviewJukka Larja2018/08/14 08:41 AM
          [side topic] personal supercomputer (Threadripper 32 core review)hobold2018/08/16 04:47 AM
  Threadripper 32 core reviewAlberto2018/08/13 11:11 AM
    Threadripper 32 core reviewMaynard Handley2018/08/13 01:27 PM
      Threadripper 32 core reviewDoug S2018/08/13 02:01 PM
        Threadripper 32 core reviewAlberto2018/08/14 02:50 AM
          Threadripper 32 core reviewnone2018/08/14 05:08 AM
          On revenues and right choicesAM2018/08/14 08:33 AM
      Threadripper 32 core reviewAlberto2018/08/14 12:57 AM
        Threadripper 32 core reviewJeff S.2018/08/14 07:00 AM
        Shrinks and power densityAM2018/08/14 08:49 AM
          Shrinks and power densityDavid Hess2018/08/18 01:30 PM
            Shrinks and power densityAM2018/08/19 08:12 AM
              Shrinks and power densityanonymou52018/08/19 09:13 PM
                Shrinks and power densityJohn H2018/08/20 05:16 PM
        Threadripper 32 core reviewDavid Hess2018/08/18 01:43 PM
  Threadripper 32 core reviewanon2018/08/13 02:48 PM
    Threadripper 32 core reviewanon2018/08/13 03:25 PM
      *while (NT)anon2018/08/13 03:26 PM
      Threadripper 32 core reviewpgerassi2018/08/13 07:34 PM
        Threadripper 32 core reviewanon2018/08/14 05:40 AM
      Threadripper 32 core reviewGabriele Svelto2018/08/14 04:22 AM
        Threadripper 32 core reviewanon2018/08/14 05:44 AM
  Flock of Chickens.Jouni Osmala2018/08/13 08:04 PM
    Flock of Chickens.none2018/08/14 01:43 AM
      AnandTech review clarityJeff S.2018/08/14 05:06 AM
        AnandTech review claritynone2018/08/14 05:15 AM
          AnandTech review clarityJeff S.2018/08/14 05:36 AM
            AnandTech review claritynone2018/08/14 05:44 AM
            AnandTech review claritynone2018/08/14 05:53 AM
Reply to this Topic
Name:
Email:
Topic:
Body: No Text
How do you spell green?