RISC-V inferior to ARMv8

By: dmcq (dmcq.delete@this.fano.co.uk), December 22, 2018 10:41 am
Room: Moderated Discussions
Michael S (already5chosen.delete@this.yahoo.com) on December 22, 2018 8:15 am wrote:
> Travis Downs (travis.downs.delete@this.gmail.com) on December 22, 2018 7:50 am wrote:
> > dmcq (dmcq.delete@this.fano.co.uk) on December 22, 2018 7:45 am wrote:
> >
> > > Have Arm said cmov must be implemented as including a dependency for the value that is not used?
> > > Would it be broken if it were implemented as if it were cracked into a conditional branch and moves?
> > > If there is no register dependency on the value that is not used then it can be implemented as either
> > > one instruction or cracked into an if then else depending on whether the condition was easily predictable
> > > or not. The reliability of a prediction can be got with the usual predictors and it is useful in
> > > saying when to give up rather than wasting resources going down a rabbit hole.
> >
> > I imagine there is no technical barrier to this, in the same way
> > that short forward branches can be converted the other way.
> >
> > However, you'd be opening yourself up to a lot of justifiable
> > anger from people who implemented security-sensitive
> > algorithms in a constant-time manner using cmov/predication to avoid branches if you turned it back into
> > an unpredictably behaving brach - opening the side-channel they had tried to close.
> >
> > The idea is interesting though since hardware is the one agent
> > in the system that knows for sure the runtime behavior now.
>
> "Justifiable anger" are mild words. I'd rather say "black mark". Unrepairable loss of reputation.

There is a run time option in ARMv8 to say that CSEL, their version of cmov, should take a constant time.
< Previous Post in ThreadNext Post in Thread >
TopicPosted ByDate
RISC-V Summit ProceedingsGabriele Svelto2018/12/19 08:36 AM
  RISC-V gut feelingsKonrad Schwarz2018/12/20 04:30 AM
    RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Heikki Kultala2018/12/20 07:36 AM
      RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Wilco2018/12/20 01:31 PM
        RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Travis Downs2018/12/20 02:18 PM
          RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Wilco2018/12/21 03:43 AM
            RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Ronald Maas2018/12/21 09:35 AM
          RISC-V inferior to ARMv8juanrga2018/12/21 10:28 AM
            RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Maynard Handley2018/12/21 02:39 PM
              RISC-V inferior to ARMv8anon2018/12/21 03:38 PM
                RISC-V inferior to ARMv8juanrga2018/12/23 04:39 AM
                  With similar logic nor do frequency (NT)Megol2018/12/23 09:45 AM
              RISC-V inferior to ARMv8juanrga2018/12/23 04:44 AM
                RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Wilco2018/12/23 06:21 AM
      RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Michael S2018/12/20 03:24 PM
        RISC-V inferior to ARMv8anon2018/12/20 04:22 PM
          RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Travis Downs2018/12/21 06:16 PM
            RISC-V inferior to ARMv8anon2018/12/22 03:53 AM
              Execution runtimes and SpectreFoo_2018/12/22 06:02 AM
        RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Adrian2018/12/20 08:51 PM
          RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Doug S2018/12/20 11:10 PM
            RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Adrian2018/12/20 11:38 PM
              RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Michael S2018/12/21 02:31 AM
                RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Adrian2018/12/21 03:23 AM
            RISC-V inferior to ARMv8random person2018/12/21 02:04 AM
              RISC-V inferior to ARMv8dmcq2018/12/21 04:27 AM
              RISC-V inferior to ARMv8juanrga2018/12/21 10:36 AM
              RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Doug S2018/12/21 12:02 PM
            RISC-V inferior to ARMv8juanrga2018/12/21 10:23 AM
          RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Adrian2018/12/20 11:21 PM
          RISC-V inferior to ARMv8anon2018/12/21 01:48 AM
            RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Adrian2018/12/21 03:44 AM
              RISC-V inferior to ARMv8anon2018/12/21 05:24 AM
            RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Adrian2018/12/21 04:09 AM
              RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Wilco2018/12/21 04:28 AM
          RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Michael S2018/12/21 02:27 AM
            RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Gabriele Svelto2018/12/21 01:09 PM
              RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Maynard Handley2018/12/21 02:58 PM
              RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Wilco2018/12/21 03:43 PM
                RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Travis Downs2018/12/21 05:45 PM
                  RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Wilco2018/12/22 04:37 AM
                    RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Travis Downs2018/12/22 06:54 AM
                      RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Wilco2018/12/22 10:32 AM
                Cracking is not freeGabriele Svelto2018/12/22 02:09 AM
                  Cracking is not freeWilco2018/12/22 04:32 AM
                    Cracking is not freeTravis Downs2018/12/22 07:07 AM
                      Cracking is not freeWilco2018/12/22 07:38 AM
                        Cracking is not freeTravis Downs2018/12/22 07:47 AM
                          Cracking is not freeWilco2018/12/22 10:24 AM
                            Cracking is not freeTravis Downs2018/12/25 03:41 PM
                              Cracking is not freeanon.12018/12/25 08:14 PM
                        multi-instruction decode and renamePaul A. Clayton2018/12/22 06:45 PM
                    Cracking is not freeGabriele Svelto2018/12/22 12:30 PM
                      Cracking is not freeWilco2018/12/23 06:48 AM
                      Cracking is not freeMichael S2018/12/23 08:09 AM
                        Cracking is not freeGabriele Svelto2018/12/26 02:53 PM
          RISC-V inferior to ARMv8rwessel2018/12/21 01:13 PM
          RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Seni2018/12/21 02:33 PM
            RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Wilco2018/12/21 03:33 PM
              RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Travis Downs2018/12/21 05:49 PM
                RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Wilco2018/12/22 04:58 AM
                  RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Travis Downs2018/12/22 07:03 AM
                    RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Wilco2018/12/22 07:22 AM
                      RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Travis Downs2018/12/22 07:40 AM
        RISC-V inferior to ARMv8dmcq2018/12/21 03:57 AM
      RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Konrad Schwarz2018/12/21 02:25 AM
      RISC-V inferior to ARMv8j2018/12/21 10:46 AM
        RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Travis Downs2018/12/21 06:08 PM
          RISC-V inferior to ARMv8dmcq2018/12/22 07:45 AM
            RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Travis Downs2018/12/22 07:50 AM
              RISC-V inferior to ARMv8Michael S2018/12/22 08:15 AM
                RISC-V inferior to ARMv8dmcq2018/12/22 10:41 AM
        RISC-V inferior to ARMv8AnonQ2018/12/22 08:13 AM
    RISC-V gut feelingsdmcq2018/12/20 07:41 AM
      RISC-V initial takeKonrad Schwarz2018/12/21 02:17 AM
        RISC-V initial takedmcq2018/12/21 03:23 AM
      RISC-V gut feelingsMontaray Jack2018/12/22 02:56 PM
        RISC-V gut feelingsdmcq2018/12/23 04:38 AM
  RISC-V Summit Proceedingsjuanrga2018/12/21 10:47 AM
    RISC-V Summit Proceedingsdmcq2018/12/22 06:21 AM
      RISC-V Summit ProceedingsMontaray Jack2018/12/22 02:03 PM
        RISC-V Summit Proceedingsdmcq2018/12/23 04:39 AM
  RISC-V Summit Proceedingsanon22018/12/21 10:57 AM
    RISC-V Summit ProceedingsMichael S2018/12/22 08:36 AM
      RISC-V Summit ProceedingsAnon2018/12/22 05:51 PM
      Not Stanford MIPS but commercial MIPSPaul A. Clayton2018/12/23 03:05 AM
        Not Stanford MIPS but commercial MIPSMichael S2018/12/23 03:49 AM
        Not Stanford MIPS but commercial MIPSdmcq2018/12/23 04:52 AM
Reply to this Topic
Name:
Email:
Topic:
Body: No Text
How do you spell green?