# New Silicon Insider Article

Article: Escape From the Planet of x86
By: Tvar' (unununium.delete@this.hotmail.com), June 18, 2003 3:41 pm
>Yeah, half does seem a little optimistic. However, we know the 1.3GHz part has
>half the L3 cache, and cache leakage power is 7% of the 130W by itself. Going from
>the chart, and using the "chip power scales linearly with clock and as the square of voltage" approximations...
>
>Take out ~5W for half the cache
>125W * 1.3/1.5 = 108W
>108W * 1.1^2/1.3^2 = 77W
>
>We aren't at 65W (half power), but it's not all that far away, assuming the 1.3GHz
>chip uses a 1.1V source and the 1.5GHz chip uses the 1.3V source. I'm not sure
>that's a safe assumption to make, but 77W isn't too horrendous for the amount of
>performance that a 1.3GHz Itanium2 is likely to deliver. The only way that you
>could get those last 12W back is if somehow going to 1.1V from 1.3V *significantly*
>reduced leakage in the chip, on the order of what, about two thirds?

But you already assumed an overoptimistic leakage reduction because you didn't take out core leakage in the above calculation, and you assumed I/O power scaled along with dynamic core power.

I understand that only *Dynamic power* is proportional to V^2*F. Leakage by definition gets no frequency reduction benefit, and I doubt that leakage reduces with the square of supply voltage. I/O power is on a separate vcc and frequency determined, and it won't scale either.

I see it like this:

Power of 6 MB, 1.3 V, 1.5 GHz Madison using percentages from pdf:
```Cache leakage  9.1 W
Core leakage   18.2 W
I/O            6.5 W
Dynamic power  96.2 W
Total          130 W
```
3 MB, 1.1 V, 1.3 GHz
```
Cache leakage   4.55 W
Core leakage    18.2 W
I/O             6.5 W
Dynamic power   59.69 W
Total           88.94 W
```
I don't see how a 1.3 GHz, 1.1 V, 3 MB Madison will get close to 65 W.
TopicPosted ByDate
New Silicon Insider ArticleDavid Kanter2003/06/17 03:39 PM
Srockholm Syndromeanonymous2003/06/17 03:50 PM
Srockholm SyndromeNate Begeman2003/06/17 04:32 PM
Srockholm Syndromeanonymous2003/06/18 02:23 PM
Srockholm SyndromeScott Robinson2003/06/20 08:25 AM
New Silicon Insider ArticleBill Todd2003/06/17 09:51 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleAlberto2003/06/18 07:29 AM
New Silicon Insider ArticleJosé Javier Zarate2003/06/18 10:16 AM
New Silicon Insider ArticleBill Todd2003/06/18 03:10 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleNate Begeman2003/06/18 03:25 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleTvar'2003/06/18 03:41 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleAlberto2003/06/18 03:58 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleTvar'2003/06/18 04:04 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleAlberto2003/06/18 04:24 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleTvar'2003/06/18 04:32 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticlePaul DeMone2003/06/18 04:13 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleTvar'2003/06/18 04:23 PM
New Silicon Insider Articlemas2003/06/18 04:11 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleAlberto2003/06/18 03:45 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleBill Todd2003/06/18 11:46 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleDavid Wang2003/06/19 12:13 AM
New Silicon Insider ArticleBill Todd2003/06/19 01:14 AM
New Silicon Insider ArticleDavid Wang2003/06/19 10:52 AM
New Silicon Insider ArticlePaul DeMone2003/06/18 04:04 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleBill Todd2003/06/18 11:28 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticlePaul DeMone2003/06/19 12:43 AM
New Silicon Insider ArticleRob Young2003/06/19 10:23 AM
New Silicon Insider ArticleBill Todd2003/06/19 04:53 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleDavid Wang2003/06/18 11:29 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleBill Todd2003/06/19 12:03 AM
New Silicon Insider ArticleJosé Javier Zarate2003/06/19 05:33 AM
New Silicon Insider Articlemas2003/06/19 06:37 AM
New Silicon Insider ArticleBill Todd2003/06/19 04:40 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleDavid Wang2003/06/19 05:25 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleBill Todd2003/06/19 06:00 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleAlberto2003/06/19 06:29 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleSpeedy2003/06/19 06:48 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleAlberto2003/06/20 04:57 AM
New Silicon Insider ArticleDavid Wang2003/06/19 06:52 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleBill Todd2003/06/19 09:00 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleAnonymous2003/06/20 02:20 AM
New Silicon Insider ArticlePaul DeMone2003/06/20 09:11 AM
New Silicon Insider ArticleAnonymous2003/06/22 04:48 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticlePaul DeMone2003/06/22 05:49 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleVincent Diepeveen2003/06/22 06:25 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleJosé Javier Zarate2003/06/22 07:55 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleAnonymous2003/06/23 09:59 AM
New Silicon Insider ArticlePaul DeMone2003/06/19 07:53 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleBill Todd2003/06/19 08:53 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleDavid Wang2003/06/19 09:08 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleBill Todd2003/06/20 02:28 AM
New Silicon Insider ArticleDavid Wang2003/06/20 11:35 AM
New Silicon Insider ArticlePaul DeMone2003/06/20 12:29 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleBill Todd2003/06/20 07:10 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleMarc M.2003/06/21 06:06 AM
New Silicon Insider ArticleBill Todd2003/06/21 12:07 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleBill Todd2003/06/20 07:01 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleDavid Wang2003/06/20 07:52 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleBill Todd2003/06/20 08:53 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleDavid Wang2003/06/20 09:14 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleVincent Diepeveen2003/06/20 09:52 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleMarc M.2003/06/21 08:16 AM
New Silicon Insider ArticleVincent Diepeveen2003/06/22 05:24 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleSingh, S.R.2003/06/21 04:39 AM
New Silicon Insider ArticleDavid Wang2003/06/21 09:10 AM
IPF CompilersNate Begeman2003/06/21 10:10 AM
IPF CompilersPaul DeMone2003/06/21 10:45 AM
Use ILP to extract more ILPPaul DeMone2003/06/20 11:48 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticlePaul DeMone2003/06/20 09:06 AM
New Silicon Insider ArticleSingh, S.R.2003/06/20 10:41 AM
New Silicon Insider ArticleDavid Kanter2003/06/21 04:34 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticlePaul DeMone2003/06/22 03:22 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleBill Todd2003/06/20 06:52 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleMarc M.2003/06/21 08:54 AM
New Silicon Insider ArticleDaniel Gustafsson2003/06/19 12:12 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticlePaul DeMone2003/06/20 03:20 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleBryan Gregory2003/06/20 02:14 PM
New Silicon Insider Articlemas2003/06/20 02:43 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticlePaul DeMone2003/06/25 11:29 AM
New Silicon Insider ArticleJosé Javier Zarate2003/06/25 11:43 AM
New Silicon Insider ArticlePaul DeMone2003/06/25 11:52 AM
lol, amazing coincidence :-) (NT)mas2003/06/25 04:15 PM
New Silicon Insider ArticleYoav2015/04/01 04:43 AM