By: Adrian (a.delete@this.acm.org), January 2, 2021 1:03 am
Room: Moderated Discussions
Jukka Larja (roskakori2006.delete@this.gmail.com) on January 1, 2021 9:53 pm wrote:
>
> I just checked one retailer with 175 AM4 motherboards listed. Only 5 were advertising ECC support
> (actually, only 5 had "ECC" written in description. I presume they all had it because they support
> ECC DIMMs). None of the 14 TRX40 motherboards had ECC support listed. I have no idea if support
> is actually that bad or if it's just something manufacturers aren't interested in advertising.
> Either way, if I was really willing to pay for ECC (both in money and in having to get less suitable
> motherboard and doing more work), I would look for something with official support.
>
> -JLarja
Normally it is not necessary to search though 175 or more motherboards for AMD to find which have ECC support.
The empiric rule for which I have not noticed exceptions yet is that if you want ECC, you must buy either any ASRock MB or any ASUS workstation MB (so for ASUS only those clearly described as "workstation").
So just looking at the names of the MBs in a list, you know whether they support ECC or not, before verifying the detailed specifications.
The ASUS WS MBs have the additional bonus of lacking any gaming-oriented features that might be useless in a professional setting.
>
> I just checked one retailer with 175 AM4 motherboards listed. Only 5 were advertising ECC support
> (actually, only 5 had "ECC" written in description. I presume they all had it because they support
> ECC DIMMs). None of the 14 TRX40 motherboards had ECC support listed. I have no idea if support
> is actually that bad or if it's just something manufacturers aren't interested in advertising.
> Either way, if I was really willing to pay for ECC (both in money and in having to get less suitable
> motherboard and doing more work), I would look for something with official support.
>
> -JLarja
Normally it is not necessary to search though 175 or more motherboards for AMD to find which have ECC support.
The empiric rule for which I have not noticed exceptions yet is that if you want ECC, you must buy either any ASRock MB or any ASUS workstation MB (so for ASUS only those clearly described as "workstation").
So just looking at the names of the MBs in a list, you know whether they support ECC or not, before verifying the detailed specifications.
The ASUS WS MBs have the additional bonus of lacking any gaming-oriented features that might be useless in a professional setting.