ARM being a good idea doesn't mean it would have worked for AMD

By: Linus Torvalds (torvalds.delete@this.linux-foundation.org), February 22, 2021 6:06 pm
Room: Moderated Discussions
Dummond D. Slow (mental.delete@this.protozoa.us) on February 22, 2021 1:34 pm wrote:
>
> I don't disagree on the principle but hurdles for getting into phone market are
> so high it makes almost no sense to try to butt in forcefully - for AMD.

The only place I see AMD succeeding with an ARM strategy would be with a strong partner that didn't want to do their own chips.

The main one that comes to mind is Microsoft, but they went with Qualcomm. That end result obviously hasn't been earth-shattering, but it's not like MS has really shown any inclination of going all-in on ARM, so who knows where the blame lies.

The server (mainly big cloud providers) market seems to just want to do their own chips entirely, and it's not clear what would be in it for AMD. That market would seem to make more sense for a small chip house that wants to be bought out, than for somebody like AMD.

The phone/tablet market is already locked in, as you say.

So what ARM market does that leave AMD? They can't create a market for ARM chips on their own, and the existing ones don't seem like great fits. A Surface partnership with Microsoft still seems like the best option to me, but you'd have to have a great core and go to MS and say "look, the Qualcomm partnership isn't doing it for you, here's what we can do".

And then hope that the WARM market really takes off.

Considering how well AMD is doing on the x86 side, they may not have a lot of incentive to really try to grow the WARM market, though. Yeah, competing against Intel isn't always wonderful, but competing against everybody else doesn't seem to be the solution either. Waiting for Intel to stumble seems to have worked out for them.

Linus
< Previous Post in ThreadNext Post in Thread >
TopicPosted ByDate
New Lex Fridman interview with Jim KellerJohnG2021/02/20 12:25 AM
  12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much" (NT)Moritz2021/02/20 10:45 AM
    AAARGH, what are we going to argue about then? (NT)j2021/02/20 03:43 PM
    Blasphemy! (NT):]2021/02/21 05:49 AM
    12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"anon22021/02/21 11:25 PM
      12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Brett2021/02/22 12:59 AM
        12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Etienne Lorrain2021/02/22 02:17 AM
      12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Dummond D. Slow2021/02/22 09:57 AM
        12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Anon2021/02/22 11:52 AM
          12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"juanrga2021/02/22 12:01 PM
          12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Mark Roulo2021/02/22 12:54 PM
          ARM being a good idea doesn't mean it would have worked for AMDDummond D. Slow2021/02/22 02:34 PM
            ARM being a good idea doesn't mean it would have worked for AMDAnon2021/02/22 04:25 PM
              ARM being a good idea doesn't mean it would have worked for AMDDummond D. Slow2021/02/22 05:55 PM
                ARM being a good idea doesn't mean it would have worked for AMDDoug S2021/02/23 01:03 PM
                  ARM being a good idea doesn't mean it would have worked for AMDDummond D. Slow2021/02/23 01:27 PM
                    ARM being a good idea doesn't mean it would have worked for AMDBrett2021/02/23 04:57 PM
                      3rd parties licensing ARM coresAnon2021/02/25 05:01 AM
                        3rd parties licensing ARM coresAnon2021/02/25 05:48 AM
                        3rd parties licensing ARM coresdmcq2021/02/25 07:01 AM
                          3rd parties licensing ARM coresDummond D. Slow2021/02/25 10:17 AM
                            3rd parties licensing ARM coresAnon2021/02/25 11:11 AM
                              3rd parties licensing ARM coresAnon2021/02/26 03:54 AM
                              3rd parties licensing ARM coresDummond D. Slow2021/02/26 11:01 AM
            ARM being a good idea doesn't mean it would have worked for AMDLinus Torvalds2021/02/22 06:06 PM
              ARM being a good idea doesn't mean it would have worked for AMDDummond D. Slow2021/02/22 08:19 PM
              ARM being a good idea doesn't mean it would have worked for AMDanon22021/02/22 08:28 PM
              ARM being a good idea doesn't mean it would have worked for AMDdmcq2021/02/23 06:35 AM
                ARM being a good idea doesn't mean it would have worked for AMDJukka Larja2021/02/23 08:12 AM
                  ARM being a good idea doesn't mean it would have worked for AMDSimon Farnsworth2021/02/23 09:42 AM
                    ARM being a good idea doesn't mean it would have worked for AMDJukka Larja2021/02/24 07:03 AM
                ARM may have been a threat to Intelwumpus2021/02/23 09:30 AM
      12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"blaine2021/02/22 10:37 AM
        12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"anon22021/02/22 08:17 PM
          12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Anon2021/02/23 04:05 AM
            12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Wilco2021/02/23 04:48 AM
              12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Bigos2021/02/23 04:55 AM
                12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Wilco2021/02/23 05:15 AM
                  12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Bigos2021/02/23 06:16 AM
                12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Travis Downs2021/02/27 12:46 AM
              12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Anon2021/02/23 07:26 AM
                12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"anon22021/02/23 05:35 PM
                  12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Anon2021/02/24 08:57 AM
                12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Wilco2021/02/24 05:37 AM
                  12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Etienne Lorrain2021/02/24 07:24 AM
                    12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Anon2021/02/24 09:11 AM
                    12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"rwessel2021/02/24 09:45 AM
                      12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Etienne Lorrain2021/02/25 02:02 AM
                        12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"rwessel2021/02/25 05:51 AM
                        12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Anon2021/02/25 05:53 AM
                  12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Anon2021/02/24 09:07 AM
                    12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Wilco2021/02/24 12:37 PM
                      runtime selection vs. heterogenous cores?Matt Sayler2021/02/24 07:10 PM
                        runtime selection vs. heterogenous cores?Wilco2021/02/26 06:22 AM
            12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"anon22021/02/23 05:20 AM
              12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Anon2021/02/23 07:21 AM
                12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"none2021/02/23 08:37 AM
                  12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"rwessel2021/02/23 10:44 AM
                    12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"anon22021/02/23 05:30 PM
                      12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Anon2021/02/24 09:25 AM
                        12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"anon.12021/02/25 07:13 AM
                  12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Anon2021/02/24 09:44 AM
                12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"anon22021/02/23 04:51 PM
                  12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Anon2021/02/24 09:31 AM
            12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"vvid2021/02/23 07:41 AM
              12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Michael S2021/02/23 09:52 AM
                12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"rwessel2021/02/23 10:33 AM
                  12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Linus Torvalds2021/02/23 12:44 PM
                    12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"rwessel2021/02/23 01:21 PM
                      12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Linus Torvalds2021/02/23 01:30 PM
                        12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Andrey2021/02/25 04:06 AM
                          12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Anon2021/02/25 06:04 AM
                            12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Andrey2021/02/25 06:54 AM
                              12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Anon2021/02/25 07:33 AM
                          12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Linus Torvalds2021/02/25 11:35 AM
                            12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Andrey2021/02/25 02:34 PM
                              12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Etienne Lorrain2021/02/26 02:18 AM
                              12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"dmcq2021/02/26 04:23 PM
                12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Anon2021/02/24 09:45 AM
              12:30 "[ISA] do not matter very much"Gabriele Svelto2021/02/23 10:15 AM
          Context of ISA doesn't matterPaul A. Clayton2021/02/26 01:03 PM
  Is there a text version? (NT)Foo_2021/02/20 05:33 PM
    good question (NT)Michael S2021/02/21 05:31 AM
    Is there a text version?:]2021/02/21 11:34 AM
Reply to this Topic
Name:
Email:
Topic:
Body: No Text
How do you spell tangerine? 🍊