memory errors

By: dmcq (, March 4, 2021 6:40 am
Room: Moderated Discussions
Etienne Lorrain ( on March 4, 2021 6:26 am wrote:
> dmcq ( on March 4, 2021 5:16 am wrote:
> > ...
> >
> > I think the important thing is error detection - not recovery. Error recovery at a low level is nice to
> > have but if the whole business can be fixed at a higher level and the error rate is low enough it is not
> > really necessary. Intel leaving out ECC was dreadful, the
> > thing that I think was really criminal and cretinous
> > though was cutting out even parity checking. I see it as a cheap trick to obscure errors so people just
> > blamed gremlins and pressed ctrl-alt-delete rather than fixing underlyng problems. Of course some memory
> > problems would escape that but it would catch memory that is failing and it would give an indication of
> > how reliable it is overall.
> Historically, I think ECC error detection was removed approximately at the time it took too much time to
> initialise the memory. At power-up, the parity bit is not initialised: if you dump the DDR before initialisation
> you get mostly zero bits but you will also get bits set (I do not know why the capacitor is still charged
> at power-up). If you do a quick power-cycle, it is obvious you will still have bits set.
> When the memory of the PC increased to few tens of megabytes, the CPU (at that time) was
> not able to clear that DRAM (so initialise the ECC) in less than 10 seconds, and the PC never
> had a powerful DMA to do such work. To cut boot time, they removed the parity bit.
> The problem of when to initialise ECC is still there, and on some embedded system I worked on,
> I was intentionally setting ECC errors on every ECC lines at boot to be sure the O.S. (when present,
> or the bootloader) do not use directly uninitialised memory. Obviously you can only do that if
> you take control of the CPU just after reset, any "secure boot" stuff will not help.
> You need to ensure you initialise the ECC correctly, one usual problem is if
> you write less than an ECC line, you may get an ECC error at write time.
> That is why IHMO the O.S. should manage itself any ECC (non recoverable) error, ignore it if it
> is new memory allocated to a process, correct it if it comes from a file-backed page, and stop
> the owning process(es) if necessary (i.e. cannot correct). And log the address of the error.
> Having "secure boot" and virtual boxes do not help, but giving only
> invalid ECC memory block would probably also detect bugs there.

Sounds interesting using ECC to detect uninitialised memory.

The initialisation problem could have been easily solved by simply only initialising a page when it was allocated, or ovcerwriting it if it is set from disk. You'd still get some seconds spent on the job but the user wouldn't notice. I can't really believe they wouldn't think of that never mind that booting took a long time anyway so this would be no sort of great gain.

< Previous Post in ThreadNext Post in Thread >
TopicPosted ByDate
CPU & Memory bit flipsGanon2021/03/03 09:05 AM
  Also "Silent Data Corruption"Adrian2021/03/03 10:42 AM
    Thanks for the referenceGanon2021/03/03 11:47 AM
  Implications for linux page cacheanon2021/03/03 11:54 AM
    Implications for linux page cacheLinus Torvalds2021/03/03 01:54 PM
      memory errorsblaine2021/03/03 02:53 PM
        memory errorsanon22021/03/03 05:30 PM
          memory errorsdmcq2021/03/04 05:16 AM
            memory errorsEtienne Lorrain2021/03/04 06:26 AM
              memory errorsdmcq2021/03/04 06:40 AM
                memory errorsEtienne Lorrain2021/03/04 06:58 AM
                  memory errorsdmcq2021/03/04 07:12 AM
                  memory errorsCarson2021/03/05 02:31 AM
                    memory errorsEtienne Lorrain2021/03/05 06:23 AM
                      memory errorsrwessel2021/03/05 07:48 AM
                      memory errorsdmcq2021/03/05 12:01 PM
                        memory errorsrwessel2021/03/05 12:23 PM
                          memory errorsdmcq2021/03/05 12:51 PM
                      memory errorsBrendan2021/03/05 11:38 PM
                      memory errorsCarson2021/03/06 01:35 AM
                        memory errorsCarson2021/03/06 06:24 AM
                memory errorsDavid Hess2021/03/04 01:44 PM
                  memory errorsrwessel2021/03/04 05:14 PM
                  memory errorsLinus Torvalds2021/03/04 08:21 PM
                    memory errorsanon22021/03/04 09:46 PM
                      memory errorsCarson2021/03/05 02:43 AM
                        memory errorsanon22021/03/05 07:55 AM
                    memory errorsgallier22021/03/05 02:22 AM
                  memory errorsdmcq2021/03/05 12:59 PM
                    memory errorsDavid Hess2021/03/06 04:27 AM
                      memory errorsCarson2021/03/06 06:44 AM
                      memory errorsGabriele Svelto2021/03/06 10:11 AM
                        memory errorsDavid Hess2021/03/06 10:28 AM
                          memory errorsMichael S2021/03/06 02:45 PM
              memory errorsDoug S2021/03/04 10:48 AM
                memory errorsMichael S2021/03/04 11:36 AM
              memory errorsJörn Engel2021/03/04 03:32 PM
                memory errorsLinus Torvalds2021/03/04 08:47 PM
                  memory errorsEtienne Lorrain2021/03/05 01:09 AM
                  memory errorsMichael S2021/03/05 04:06 AM
                    memory errorsLinus Torvalds2021/03/05 11:59 AM
                      memory errorsrwessel2021/03/05 12:32 PM
                        memory errorsrwessel2021/03/05 12:37 PM
                        memory errorszArchJon2021/03/06 08:39 PM
                      memory errorsGabriele Svelto2021/03/06 12:58 PM
                  memory errorsJörn Engel2021/03/05 10:12 AM
                Amiga recoverable RAM disk?Carson2021/03/05 03:03 AM
                  Thanks - TIL a cool Amiga feature (nt) (NT)John2021/03/05 12:51 PM
                    Another cool Amiga feature, datatypesCharles2021/03/06 12:01 AM
                      Another cool Amiga feature, datatypesJukka Larja2021/03/06 01:23 AM
                      Another cool Amiga feature, datatypesAnon2021/03/06 12:40 PM
                      Another cool Amiga feature, filesystemsMarcus2021/03/07 12:28 AM
  CPU & Memory bit flipszArchJon2021/03/04 06:39 AM
    CPU & Memory bit flipsdmcq2021/03/04 06:59 AM
      CPU & Memory bit flipsrwessel2021/03/04 12:27 PM
  speak of the devilRobert Williams2021/03/05 07:53 AM
    speak of the devildmcq2021/03/05 11:26 AM
      speak of the devilRobert Williams2021/03/05 03:15 PM
Reply to this Topic
Body: No Text
How do you spell avocado?