memory errors

By: Carson (, March 6, 2021 2:35 am
Room: Moderated Discussions
Etienne Lorrain ( on March 5, 2021 6:23 am wrote:
> Nowadays things have changed, the EFI system is a lot more complicated, its whole behaviour/specification
> is under NDA (Non Disclosure Agreement), and secure boot will stop you implementing anything
> which is not approved by the manufacturer - or not supported by Window 10.
> So basically none of your sophisticated idea can be implemented, if ECC has to be supported
> it has to be done by the EFI BIOS (Windows10 do not want to hear about ECC), and you get
> what Linus was complaining about: a machine-check exception with no way to know even the
> processor which triggered the ECC error or the address which caused the problem.
> That is what people call progress: a nice background image telling you how intelligent you
> are by having bought this top of the range brand of PC, during the whole Windows boot time.

Rubbish. The basic technique I described is applicable to traditional BIOS and (U)EFI PC boot ROMs, CoreBoot, u-Boot on ARM, or any other boot system. (The main difference being that it's almost certainly easier to communicate the required information across a less kludgey boot loader interface.)

The basic concept of a chain of boot loaders, each of which uses a limited subset of system resources (including RAM), followed by a "final OS" which tries to use everything, is pretty universal.

The point is that you have a safe-but-slow fallback of initializing all of RAM. Each stage in the boot loader chain verifies that the following stage can handle uninitialized ECC, or falls back if not. (One thing I forgot to include explicitly

Getting all the details right would involve a lot of grovelling through standards (the latest UEFI specification is 2557 pages!), but that's the textbook definition of a Small Matter of Programming: conceptually straightforward but hellishly laborious.

< Previous Post in ThreadNext Post in Thread >
TopicPosted ByDate
CPU & Memory bit flipsGanon2021/03/03 10:05 AM
  Also "Silent Data Corruption"Adrian2021/03/03 11:42 AM
    Thanks for the referenceGanon2021/03/03 12:47 PM
  Implications for linux page cacheanon2021/03/03 12:54 PM
    Implications for linux page cacheLinus Torvalds2021/03/03 02:54 PM
      memory errorsblaine2021/03/03 03:53 PM
        memory errorsanon22021/03/03 06:30 PM
          memory errorsdmcq2021/03/04 06:16 AM
            memory errorsEtienne Lorrain2021/03/04 07:26 AM
              memory errorsdmcq2021/03/04 07:40 AM
                memory errorsEtienne Lorrain2021/03/04 07:58 AM
                  memory errorsdmcq2021/03/04 08:12 AM
                  memory errorsCarson2021/03/05 03:31 AM
                    memory errorsEtienne Lorrain2021/03/05 07:23 AM
                      memory errorsrwessel2021/03/05 08:48 AM
                      memory errorsdmcq2021/03/05 01:01 PM
                        memory errorsrwessel2021/03/05 01:23 PM
                          memory errorsdmcq2021/03/05 01:51 PM
                      memory errorsBrendan2021/03/06 12:38 AM
                      memory errorsCarson2021/03/06 02:35 AM
                        memory errorsCarson2021/03/06 07:24 AM
                memory errorsDavid Hess2021/03/04 02:44 PM
                  memory errorsrwessel2021/03/04 06:14 PM
                  memory errorsLinus Torvalds2021/03/04 09:21 PM
                    memory errorsanon22021/03/04 10:46 PM
                      memory errorsCarson2021/03/05 03:43 AM
                        memory errorsanon22021/03/05 08:55 AM
                    memory errorsgallier22021/03/05 03:22 AM
                  memory errorsdmcq2021/03/05 01:59 PM
                    memory errorsDavid Hess2021/03/06 05:27 AM
                      memory errorsCarson2021/03/06 07:44 AM
                      memory errorsGabriele Svelto2021/03/06 11:11 AM
                        memory errorsDavid Hess2021/03/06 11:28 AM
                          memory errorsMichael S2021/03/06 03:45 PM
              memory errorsDoug S2021/03/04 11:48 AM
                memory errorsMichael S2021/03/04 12:36 PM
              memory errorsJörn Engel2021/03/04 04:32 PM
                memory errorsLinus Torvalds2021/03/04 09:47 PM
                  memory errorsEtienne Lorrain2021/03/05 02:09 AM
                  memory errorsMichael S2021/03/05 05:06 AM
                    memory errorsLinus Torvalds2021/03/05 12:59 PM
                      memory errorsrwessel2021/03/05 01:32 PM
                        memory errorsrwessel2021/03/05 01:37 PM
                        memory errorszArchJon2021/03/06 09:39 PM
                      memory errorsGabriele Svelto2021/03/06 01:58 PM
                  memory errorsJörn Engel2021/03/05 11:12 AM
                Amiga recoverable RAM disk?Carson2021/03/05 04:03 AM
                  Thanks - TIL a cool Amiga feature (nt) (NT)John2021/03/05 01:51 PM
                    Another cool Amiga feature, datatypesCharles2021/03/06 01:01 AM
                      Another cool Amiga feature, datatypesJukka Larja2021/03/06 02:23 AM
                      Another cool Amiga feature, datatypesAnon2021/03/06 01:40 PM
                      Another cool Amiga feature, filesystemsMarcus2021/03/07 01:28 AM
  CPU & Memory bit flipszArchJon2021/03/04 07:39 AM
    CPU & Memory bit flipsdmcq2021/03/04 07:59 AM
      CPU & Memory bit flipsrwessel2021/03/04 01:27 PM
  speak of the devilRobert Williams2021/03/05 08:53 AM
    speak of the devildmcq2021/03/05 12:26 PM
      speak of the devilRobert Williams2021/03/05 04:15 PM
Reply to this Topic
Body: No Text
How do you spell avocado?