By: --- (---.delete@this.redheron.com), January 26, 2023 10:37 am
Room: Moderated Discussions
The NYT article on SPR
https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/10/technology/intel-sapphire-rapids-microprocessor.html
is as journalistic and NYTish as you'd expect, but does include a few actually valuable nuggets.
For example we are told that SPR discussions began in 2015. This is interesting in so far as I've suggested before that Intel's primary problem (whether caused by x86 or other concerns) is slow turnaround, taking ~7yrs to complete what Apple and ARM are doing in ~4yrs.
Likewise they seem to not have adequate control of complexity, given that the SPR delays are blamed more on design/validation flaws rather than process delay. Of course covid hurt (like it hurt everyone) so I'm willing to give some slack on that.
One could also throw marketing in the mix insofar as (see for example Patrick's STH analyses) most customers will probably not be using SPR's accelerators, but they were part of that complexity and thus the delay. A wiser company might, perhaps, have developed the accelerator IP on a different track, ready to add to the system when it was validated, but not delaying the bread-and-butter product for untested tech?
Overall I find little in the article to make me positive as to Intel's execution capabilities. There's a whole lot of "mea culpa, mea maxima culpa" but every flaw that they admit to was a flaw that was clear five years ago, so it's not obvious why THIS time the mea-culpa'ing is any more serious. ( Claims about streamlining the product road map! Anyone believe that??? )
https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/10/technology/intel-sapphire-rapids-microprocessor.html
is as journalistic and NYTish as you'd expect, but does include a few actually valuable nuggets.
For example we are told that SPR discussions began in 2015. This is interesting in so far as I've suggested before that Intel's primary problem (whether caused by x86 or other concerns) is slow turnaround, taking ~7yrs to complete what Apple and ARM are doing in ~4yrs.
Likewise they seem to not have adequate control of complexity, given that the SPR delays are blamed more on design/validation flaws rather than process delay. Of course covid hurt (like it hurt everyone) so I'm willing to give some slack on that.
One could also throw marketing in the mix insofar as (see for example Patrick's STH analyses) most customers will probably not be using SPR's accelerators, but they were part of that complexity and thus the delay. A wiser company might, perhaps, have developed the accelerator IP on a different track, ready to add to the system when it was validated, but not delaying the bread-and-butter product for untested tech?
Overall I find little in the article to make me positive as to Intel's execution capabilities. There's a whole lot of "mea culpa, mea maxima culpa" but every flaw that they admit to was a flaw that was clear five years ago, so it's not obvious why THIS time the mea-culpa'ing is any more serious. ( Claims about streamlining the product road map! Anyone believe that??? )
Topic | Posted By | Date |
---|---|---|
NYT on SPR | --- | 2023/01/26 10:37 AM |
NYT on SPR | Chris G | 2023/01/26 06:02 PM |
NYT on SPR | me | 2023/01/26 07:44 PM |
NYT on SPR | Anne O. Nymous | 2023/01/27 01:09 AM |
NYT on SPR | Michael S | 2023/01/27 03:22 AM |
NYT on SPR | --- | 2023/01/27 10:31 AM |
Pat has been trimming the Intel product portfolio | Mark Roulo | 2023/01/27 01:29 PM |
NYT on SPR | James | 2023/01/27 02:00 PM |
NYT on SPR | Adrian | 2023/01/28 03:55 AM |
NYT on SPR | anonymou5 | 2023/01/28 04:03 AM |
NYT on SPR | Adrian | 2023/01/28 04:14 AM |
NYT on SPR | Groo | 2023/01/29 09:50 AM |
NYT on SPR | Groo | 2023/01/29 09:46 AM |
NYT on SPR | Brendan | 2023/01/29 01:00 PM |
NYT on SPR | Anon4 | 2023/01/29 04:06 PM |
NYT on SPR | Brendan | 2023/01/29 07:03 PM |
NYT on SPR | Groo | 2023/01/30 07:09 AM |
NYT on SPR | Groo | 2023/01/29 09:39 AM |
NYT on SPR | AnonSoft | 2023/01/30 11:01 AM |
NYT on SPR | hobold | 2023/01/30 12:39 PM |
NYT on SPR | AnonSoft | 2023/01/30 05:34 PM |
NYT on SPR | hobold | 2023/01/31 04:40 AM |
NYT on SPR | Jukka Larja | 2023/01/31 07:13 AM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | Mark Heath | 2023/02/01 04:45 AM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | Freddie | 2023/02/01 05:05 AM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | Mark Heath | 2023/02/01 06:42 AM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | Freddie | 2023/02/01 09:54 AM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | Mark Heath | 2023/02/01 04:45 PM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | —- | 2023/02/02 04:35 PM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | Freddie | 2023/02/02 04:39 PM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | --- | 2023/02/03 12:15 PM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | Freddie | 2023/02/03 03:46 PM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | Anne O. Nymous | 2023/02/03 12:57 AM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | --- | 2023/02/03 12:35 PM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | Anne O. Nymous | 2023/02/03 01:35 PM |
different big/little split.. | Heikki Kultala | 2023/02/03 02:33 PM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | Paul H | 2023/02/03 06:51 PM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | Jukka Larja | 2023/02/01 06:24 AM |
When heavily loaded, Threads run about equally fast on E-cores than P-cores | Heikki Kultala | 2023/02/01 02:08 PM |
NYT on SPR | Chester | 2023/01/27 09:30 AM |
use archive.org | anon | 2023/01/27 06:08 PM |
Bypassing paywalls | Doug S | 2023/01/28 02:05 PM |
NYT on SPR | Chris G | 2023/01/27 06:54 PM |
Intel On Demand | Chris G | 2023/01/28 04:24 AM |
Intel On Demand | me | 2023/01/28 06:24 AM |
Intel On Demand | Groo | 2023/01/29 09:53 AM |
Intel On Demand | rwessel | 2023/01/28 09:41 AM |
Intel On Demand | --- | 2023/01/28 11:37 AM |
Anit-waste bias | Paul A. Clayton | 2023/01/28 07:57 PM |
Intel On Demand | Groo | 2023/01/29 09:58 AM |
Intel On Demand | Andrey | 2023/01/30 05:04 PM |
Intel On Demand | blaine | 2023/01/28 03:07 PM |
Intel On Demand | me | 2023/01/28 03:25 PM |
Intel On Demand | me | 2023/01/28 03:33 PM |
Intel On Demand | Chris G | 2023/01/28 07:06 PM |
Intel On Demand | me | 2023/01/28 07:43 PM |
Intel On Demand - Validation, certification? | Björn Ragnar Björnsson | 2023/01/28 10:41 PM |
Intel On Demand - Validation, certification? | anonymou5 | 2023/01/29 02:49 AM |
Sapphire Rapids crippleware is a naked money grab | Chris G | 2023/01/29 04:44 AM |
Intel On Demand - Validation, certification? | Groo | 2023/01/29 10:05 AM |
Intel On Demand - Validation, certification? | AnotherAnonymousEngineer | 2023/01/29 10:33 AM |
Intel On Demand - Validation, certification? | Groo | 2023/01/29 11:16 AM |
Intel On Demand - Validation, certification? | dmcq | 2023/01/29 04:32 PM |
Intel On Demand - Validation, certification? | Brendan | 2023/01/29 08:01 PM |
Intel On Demand - Validation, certification? | Groo | 2023/01/30 07:17 AM |
Intel On Demand - Validation, certification? | Freddie | 2023/01/30 11:36 AM |
Intel On Demand - Validation, certification? | anon2 | 2023/01/30 07:41 PM |
Intel On Demand - Validation, certification? | anon2 | 2023/01/31 01:35 AM |
Crippleware | Chris G | 2023/01/31 05:47 AM |
Doctorow calls it "enshittification" (NT) | hobold | 2023/01/31 07:55 AM |
Crippleware | anon2 | 2023/01/31 10:51 AM |
Crippleware | Groo | 2023/02/01 02:06 PM |
Crippleware | anon2 | 2023/02/01 05:10 PM |
Crippleware | Chris G | 2023/02/01 05:52 PM |
Crippleware | anon2 | 2023/02/01 09:15 PM |
SPR Volume | me | 2023/02/02 04:47 AM |
SPR Volume | anon2 | 2023/02/02 07:04 AM |
Crippleware | Chris G | 2023/02/02 08:12 AM |
Crippleware | anon2 | 2023/02/02 08:42 AM |
Crippleware | anon2 | 2023/02/02 08:48 AM |
Crippleware | Charles | 2023/02/01 01:38 AM |
Crippleware | Chris G | 2023/02/01 02:59 AM |
language digression | Matt Sayler | 2023/02/01 04:53 PM |
Crippleware | me | 2023/02/01 06:27 PM |
Crippleware | Chris G | 2023/02/01 07:01 PM |
Crippleware | me | 2023/02/01 07:10 PM |
Crippleware | Chris G | 2023/02/01 09:32 PM |
Crippleware | Tony | 2023/02/01 11:18 PM |
Crippleware | me | 2023/02/02 04:27 AM |
Crippleware | anonymou5 | 2023/02/02 03:47 AM |
Crippleware | Chris G | 2023/02/02 05:59 AM |
Intel On Demand - Enshittification | blaine | 2023/01/30 12:13 AM |
Intel and mobile phones | James | 2023/01/29 09:09 AM |
Intel and mobile phones | Maxwell | 2023/01/29 02:25 PM |
Intel and mobile phones | Groo | 2023/01/30 07:20 AM |
Intel and mobile phones | anonymous2 | 2023/01/30 11:15 AM |
Intel and mobile phones | Doug S | 2023/01/30 12:51 PM |
Intel and mobile phones | Daniel B | 2023/01/31 07:37 AM |
Intel and mobile phones | Groo | 2023/02/01 02:03 PM |
SPR HBM | me | 2023/01/29 09:17 AM |
SPR-W | me | 2023/02/17 05:41 PM |
Accelerators on AMD/ARM | Chester | 2023/01/29 05:41 PM |