By: Mark Heath (none.delete@this.none.none), February 1, 2023 4:45 am
Room: Moderated Discussions
> I don't consider E cores and asymmetry to be a particular problem any more than SMT has been.
> If the algorithm scales, then good. Just run on every thread.
In an OpenMP program, unless the P-cores are given more work to do than the E-cores, the performance would be the same as just having E-cores. When a parallel for is used to compute the elements of an array across multiple cores, OpenMP has no way of knowing during compile time how many more array indices (loop iterations) to give to the P-cores compared to the E-cores. A runtime work queue could be used (called dynamic scheduling in OpenMP), but that has more overhead than static scheduling. As far as I could determine with a few internet searches, it is not possible to measure the performance of the P-cores and E-cores on iterations of a loop and statically schedule more loop iterations to the P-cores, at least with OpenMP. Does anyone know how to use heterogeneous CPU cores for parallel for loops without the overhead of dynamic loop scheduling?
> If the algorithm scales, then good. Just run on every thread.
In an OpenMP program, unless the P-cores are given more work to do than the E-cores, the performance would be the same as just having E-cores. When a parallel for is used to compute the elements of an array across multiple cores, OpenMP has no way of knowing during compile time how many more array indices (loop iterations) to give to the P-cores compared to the E-cores. A runtime work queue could be used (called dynamic scheduling in OpenMP), but that has more overhead than static scheduling. As far as I could determine with a few internet searches, it is not possible to measure the performance of the P-cores and E-cores on iterations of a loop and statically schedule more loop iterations to the P-cores, at least with OpenMP. Does anyone know how to use heterogeneous CPU cores for parallel for loops without the overhead of dynamic loop scheduling?
Topic | Posted By | Date |
---|---|---|
NYT on SPR | --- | 2023/01/26 10:37 AM |
NYT on SPR | Chris G | 2023/01/26 06:02 PM |
NYT on SPR | me | 2023/01/26 07:44 PM |
NYT on SPR | Anne O. Nymous | 2023/01/27 01:09 AM |
NYT on SPR | Michael S | 2023/01/27 03:22 AM |
NYT on SPR | --- | 2023/01/27 10:31 AM |
Pat has been trimming the Intel product portfolio | Mark Roulo | 2023/01/27 01:29 PM |
NYT on SPR | James | 2023/01/27 02:00 PM |
NYT on SPR | Adrian | 2023/01/28 03:55 AM |
NYT on SPR | anonymou5 | 2023/01/28 04:03 AM |
NYT on SPR | Adrian | 2023/01/28 04:14 AM |
NYT on SPR | Groo | 2023/01/29 09:50 AM |
NYT on SPR | Groo | 2023/01/29 09:46 AM |
NYT on SPR | Brendan | 2023/01/29 01:00 PM |
NYT on SPR | Anon4 | 2023/01/29 04:06 PM |
NYT on SPR | Brendan | 2023/01/29 07:03 PM |
NYT on SPR | Groo | 2023/01/30 07:09 AM |
NYT on SPR | Groo | 2023/01/29 09:39 AM |
NYT on SPR | AnonSoft | 2023/01/30 11:01 AM |
NYT on SPR | hobold | 2023/01/30 12:39 PM |
NYT on SPR | AnonSoft | 2023/01/30 05:34 PM |
NYT on SPR | hobold | 2023/01/31 04:40 AM |
NYT on SPR | Jukka Larja | 2023/01/31 07:13 AM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | Mark Heath | 2023/02/01 04:45 AM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | Freddie | 2023/02/01 05:05 AM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | Mark Heath | 2023/02/01 06:42 AM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | Freddie | 2023/02/01 09:54 AM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | Mark Heath | 2023/02/01 04:45 PM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | —- | 2023/02/02 04:35 PM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | Freddie | 2023/02/02 04:39 PM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | --- | 2023/02/03 12:15 PM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | Freddie | 2023/02/03 03:46 PM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | Anne O. Nymous | 2023/02/03 12:57 AM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | --- | 2023/02/03 12:35 PM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | Anne O. Nymous | 2023/02/03 01:35 PM |
different big/little split.. | Heikki Kultala | 2023/02/03 02:33 PM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | Paul H | 2023/02/03 06:51 PM |
Heterogeneous CPU Cores With OpenMP | Jukka Larja | 2023/02/01 06:24 AM |
When heavily loaded, Threads run about equally fast on E-cores than P-cores | Heikki Kultala | 2023/02/01 02:08 PM |
NYT on SPR | Chester | 2023/01/27 09:30 AM |
use archive.org | anon | 2023/01/27 06:08 PM |
Bypassing paywalls | Doug S | 2023/01/28 02:05 PM |
NYT on SPR | Chris G | 2023/01/27 06:54 PM |
Intel On Demand | Chris G | 2023/01/28 04:24 AM |
Intel On Demand | me | 2023/01/28 06:24 AM |
Intel On Demand | Groo | 2023/01/29 09:53 AM |
Intel On Demand | rwessel | 2023/01/28 09:41 AM |
Intel On Demand | --- | 2023/01/28 11:37 AM |
Anit-waste bias | Paul A. Clayton | 2023/01/28 07:57 PM |
Intel On Demand | Groo | 2023/01/29 09:58 AM |
Intel On Demand | Andrey | 2023/01/30 05:04 PM |
Intel On Demand | blaine | 2023/01/28 03:07 PM |
Intel On Demand | me | 2023/01/28 03:25 PM |
Intel On Demand | me | 2023/01/28 03:33 PM |
Intel On Demand | Chris G | 2023/01/28 07:06 PM |
Intel On Demand | me | 2023/01/28 07:43 PM |
Intel On Demand - Validation, certification? | Björn Ragnar Björnsson | 2023/01/28 10:41 PM |
Intel On Demand - Validation, certification? | anonymou5 | 2023/01/29 02:49 AM |
Sapphire Rapids crippleware is a naked money grab | Chris G | 2023/01/29 04:44 AM |
Intel On Demand - Validation, certification? | Groo | 2023/01/29 10:05 AM |
Intel On Demand - Validation, certification? | AnotherAnonymousEngineer | 2023/01/29 10:33 AM |
Intel On Demand - Validation, certification? | Groo | 2023/01/29 11:16 AM |
Intel On Demand - Validation, certification? | dmcq | 2023/01/29 04:32 PM |
Intel On Demand - Validation, certification? | Brendan | 2023/01/29 08:01 PM |
Intel On Demand - Validation, certification? | Groo | 2023/01/30 07:17 AM |
Intel On Demand - Validation, certification? | Freddie | 2023/01/30 11:36 AM |
Intel On Demand - Validation, certification? | anon2 | 2023/01/30 07:41 PM |
Intel On Demand - Validation, certification? | anon2 | 2023/01/31 01:35 AM |
Crippleware | Chris G | 2023/01/31 05:47 AM |
Doctorow calls it "enshittification" (NT) | hobold | 2023/01/31 07:55 AM |
Crippleware | anon2 | 2023/01/31 10:51 AM |
Crippleware | Groo | 2023/02/01 02:06 PM |
Crippleware | anon2 | 2023/02/01 05:10 PM |
Crippleware | Chris G | 2023/02/01 05:52 PM |
Crippleware | anon2 | 2023/02/01 09:15 PM |
SPR Volume | me | 2023/02/02 04:47 AM |
SPR Volume | anon2 | 2023/02/02 07:04 AM |
Crippleware | Chris G | 2023/02/02 08:12 AM |
Crippleware | anon2 | 2023/02/02 08:42 AM |
Crippleware | anon2 | 2023/02/02 08:48 AM |
Crippleware | Charles | 2023/02/01 01:38 AM |
Crippleware | Chris G | 2023/02/01 02:59 AM |
language digression | Matt Sayler | 2023/02/01 04:53 PM |
Crippleware | me | 2023/02/01 06:27 PM |
Crippleware | Chris G | 2023/02/01 07:01 PM |
Crippleware | me | 2023/02/01 07:10 PM |
Crippleware | Chris G | 2023/02/01 09:32 PM |
Crippleware | Tony | 2023/02/01 11:18 PM |
Crippleware | me | 2023/02/02 04:27 AM |
Crippleware | anonymou5 | 2023/02/02 03:47 AM |
Crippleware | Chris G | 2023/02/02 05:59 AM |
Intel On Demand - Enshittification | blaine | 2023/01/30 12:13 AM |
Intel and mobile phones | James | 2023/01/29 09:09 AM |
Intel and mobile phones | Maxwell | 2023/01/29 02:25 PM |
Intel and mobile phones | Groo | 2023/01/30 07:20 AM |
Intel and mobile phones | anonymous2 | 2023/01/30 11:15 AM |
Intel and mobile phones | Doug S | 2023/01/30 12:51 PM |
Intel and mobile phones | Daniel B | 2023/01/31 07:37 AM |
Intel and mobile phones | Groo | 2023/02/01 02:03 PM |
SPR HBM | me | 2023/01/29 09:17 AM |
SPR-W | me | 2023/02/17 05:41 PM |
Accelerators on AMD/ARM | Chester | 2023/01/29 05:41 PM |