Language safety in a multithread environment

Article: Fall Processor Forum 2006: IBM's POWER6
By: Tzvetan Mikov (tzvetanmi.delete@this.yahoo.com), October 26, 2006 8:17 am
Room: Moderated Discussions
Linus Torvalds () on 10/25/06 wrote:
---------------------------
>[...]
>There was this whole other discussion a few months ago
>about memory ordering, where I was pointing out that the
>weaker memory ordering of alpha was actually much worse
>than x86 in many situations. This is one of them. You need
>to either use strict locking, or totally insane amounts
>of inappropriate memory ordering insutrctions.

While that was mostly theoretical then, I think the point is really sinking in now :-)

I think the conclusion of that discussion was that weak consistency ends up being worse than both total store ordering and release consistency, with release consistency most preferable among all.

This issue here seems somewhat orthogonal - that it is preferable to have an implicit barrier between dependent reads. I wonder is the implicit barrier cheaper than an explicit one, and why ?

>Well, I don't think "safe languages" per se is the
>problem. "Strange threaded languages with certain models
>of memory ordering, apparently including Java" - yes.

Not really. Java is actually one of the few languages that properly address threading and memory consistency in a way that is complete, intuitive and logical. As far as I can tell, any safe language that is in wide use today, including all .NET languages, Perl, Python, Lisp, ML, would have exactly the same problem on Alpha. (As far as I know, Perl, Python & friends use a global lock arround all data accesses - which is of course much worse than having read barriers)

As Gabriele explained, this is fundamental to language safety. To avoid this problem we need a language where all sharing of data between threads is explicitly controlled and known - I don't know whether that is plausible in an imperative language and how efficient it would be.

We might argue that safe languages are not that useful and we shouldn't worry about them (or design processors suitable for them). This opinion is certainly not uncommon. But since apparently only Alpha exhibits this particular problem and it is dead, we are not at such a crossroad yet.

>[...]
>Quite frankly, I don't understand how you can avoid it
>either. Your example with "GlobalPtr" didn't make much
>sense from a real example standpoint, since normally you'd
>not have one global pointer, you'd have a hash-table or
>linked list or somethign else that you expose new entries
>throgh, and that data structure needs locking
>anyway.

Well, that code is actually very real and widely used in Java. The typical scenario is when the result of a function is immutable but relatively expensive to compute, so it is cached the first time it is used.

In many cases this is done correctly by qualifying the global pointer with "volatile" (which in Java actually means something :-). This is reasonable and efficient and is a specific pattern in which you really don't need locking. (There is a small chance that more than one object will be created, but that is OK and the extra objects will be safely discarded)

In other cases the volatile is missing, which is a bug of course, but we are worried about those cases only so they don't crash the VM.

>How about just catching the SIGSEGV and telling the user
>that he messed up instead? The memory barrier is free on
>x86 (one of the reasons the x86 memory model is actually
>very nice), but on other architectures even the write
>barrier may well be fairly expensive, and it sounds like
>you're protecting against something that isn't really even
>worth protecting against.

The idea about SIGSEGV is a very interesing one. In an earlier message it was suggested to use that to recover from the problem. That seems a bit "hairy"to me, but not comletely impossible.

The alternative is, as you say, to just report the error to the user. The problem is that we don't just want to crash the application. We want such errors to have as isolated effect as possible and to be handled in a clean way. The application should be able to log the error and continue without compromising the integrity of the VM.

I will think about this.

>If you take a performance hit, at least it should be
>worth taking a hit over..

Having a predictable environment that never crashes and is always completely diagnosable is a worthy and interesting goal. It is not that expensive too, considering that many popular safe language in use today (Perl, Ruby, Python) are an order of magnitude slower than Java and C#.

Ultimately we might disagree on the usefulness of safe languages, but take it as an intellectual exercise :-)
< Previous Post in ThreadNext Post in Thread >
TopicPosted ByDate
POWER6 article onlineDavid Kanter2006/10/16 10:31 PM
  POWER6 article onlineNiels Jørgen Kruse2006/10/16 11:59 PM
    POWER6 article onlineDavid Kanter2006/10/17 12:03 AM
      Interesting cachesPaul Aaron Clayton2006/10/17 06:35 AM
  POWER6 article onlinerwessel2006/10/17 12:17 AM
    POWER6 article onlineGabriele Svelto2006/10/17 12:49 AM
      POWER6 article onlinerwessel2006/10/17 12:55 AM
      POWER6 article onlineDavid Kanter2006/10/17 01:01 AM
        POWER6 article onlineGabriele Svelto2006/10/17 01:06 AM
  BCD arithmetic remarkRob Thorpe2006/10/17 06:57 AM
    BCD arithmetic remarkDavid Kanter2006/10/17 08:04 AM
      BCD arithmetic remarkRob Thorpe2006/10/17 08:33 AM
        Java perfSerge Monkewitz2006/10/17 12:25 PM
          Java perfRob Thorpe2006/10/18 04:27 AM
            Java perfsp2006/10/18 04:50 AM
              Java perfRob Thorpe2006/10/18 08:36 AM
                Data parallelism in .NET using GPUsStephen Goss2006/10/18 11:48 PM
                  Data parallelism in .NET using GPUssp2006/10/19 01:08 AM
                    Data parallelism in .NET using GPUsStephen Goss2006/10/21 02:22 AM
                      Data parallelism in .NET using GPUsfastpathguru2006/11/01 02:30 PM
                        Data parallelism in .NET using GPUsIan Ameline2006/11/01 05:31 PM
                Java perfGabriele Svelto2006/10/19 12:23 AM
                  Java perfRob Thorpe2006/10/19 02:58 AM
              Numerical Java perfWes Felter2006/10/18 10:25 AM
                Numerical Java perfsp2006/10/18 10:46 AM
                  Numerical Java perfRob Thorpe2006/10/18 11:23 AM
                    Numerical Java perfTzvetan Mikov2006/10/18 11:44 AM
                      Numerical Java perfRob Thorpe2006/10/19 04:30 AM
                        Numerical Java perfsp2006/10/19 05:22 AM
                          Numerical Java perfGabriele Svelto2006/10/19 05:33 AM
                          Numerical Java perfRob Thorpe2006/10/19 07:08 AM
                            Numerical Java perfJuho Snellman2006/10/20 08:38 AM
                              Numerical Java perfRob Thorpe2006/10/23 04:54 AM
                                SBCL garbage collectorJuho Snellman2006/10/25 03:29 AM
                          Numerical Java perfTzvetan Mikov2006/10/19 09:04 AM
                        Language safety in a multithread environmentTzvetan Mikov2006/10/19 09:34 AM
                          Language safety in a multithread environmentRicardo B2006/10/19 11:43 AM
                            Language safety in a multithread environmentTzvetan Mikov2006/10/19 12:11 PM
                              Language safety in a multithread environmentRicardo B2006/10/19 02:23 PM
                                Language safety in a multithread environmentTzvetan Mikov2006/10/19 04:08 PM
                                  Language safety in a multithread environmentRicardo B2006/10/20 05:04 AM
                                    Language safety in a multithread environmentTzvetan Mikov2006/10/20 01:53 PM
                                      Language safety in a multithread environmentRicardo B2006/10/20 02:06 PM
                                      PSRicardo B2006/10/20 02:12 PM
                                        PSTzvetan Mikov2006/10/20 03:30 PM
                          Language safety in a multithread environmentGabriele Svelto2006/10/20 01:26 AM
                            Language safety in a multithread environmentTzvetan Mikov2006/10/20 01:34 PM
                              Language safety in a multithread environmentS. Rao2006/10/20 08:39 PM
                                Language safety in a multithread environmentTzvetan Mikov2006/10/21 09:39 AM
                                  Language safety in a multithread environmentS. Rao2006/10/21 03:54 PM
                                    Language safety in a multithread environmentRicardo B2006/10/21 04:45 PM
                                    Language safety in a multithread environmentTzvetan Mikov2006/10/22 09:42 AM
                                      Language safety in a multithread environmentRob Thorpe2006/10/23 09:35 AM
                                        Language safety in a multithread environmentLinus Torvalds2006/10/23 04:06 PM
                                          Language safety in a multithread environmentTzvetan Mikov2006/10/23 11:55 PM
                                            Language safety in a multithread environmentLinus Torvalds2006/10/24 07:35 AM
                                              Language safety in a multithread environmentTzvetan Mikov2006/10/24 11:26 AM
                                                ClarificationTzvetan Mikov2006/10/24 12:15 PM
                                                Language safety in a multithread environmentLinus Torvalds2006/10/25 07:37 AM
                                                  Language safety in a multithread environmentRob Thorpe2006/10/25 07:52 AM
                                                  Language safety in a multithread environmentTzvetan Mikov2006/10/25 09:01 AM
                                                    Language safety in a multithread environmentLinus Torvalds2006/10/25 05:24 PM
                                                      Language safety in a multithread environmentS. Rao2006/10/25 06:08 PM
                                                        Other approachesRob Thorpe2006/10/26 10:09 AM
                                                          Hang on I forgot the other approachesRob Thorpe2006/10/26 10:27 AM
                                                            Hang on I forgot the other approachesS. Rao2006/10/26 02:16 PM
                                                      Language safety in a multithread environmentGabriele Svelto2006/10/26 03:56 AM
                                                        Language safety in a multithread environmentLinus Torvalds2006/10/26 07:52 AM
                                                          Language safety in a multithread environmentGabriele Svelto2006/10/26 08:11 AM
                                                            "Safety" and different types of safetyRob Thorpe2006/10/26 08:58 AM
                                                              "Safety" and different types of safetyLinus Torvalds2006/10/26 09:26 AM
                                                                "Safety" and different types of safetyRob Thorpe2006/10/26 09:50 AM
                                                                  "Safety" and different types of safetyTzvetan Mikov2006/10/26 10:56 AM
                                                                    Exactly!Gabriele Svelto2006/10/27 12:29 AM
                                                                  message passing languagesFoo_2006/10/28 01:19 AM
                                                        Language safety in a multithread environmentRob Thorpe2006/10/26 10:45 AM
                                                          RecapTzvetan Mikov2006/10/26 11:19 AM
                                                            Information and ickiness on JavaRob Thorpe2006/10/27 04:38 AM
                                                              Excellent threadJasonB2006/10/27 02:57 PM
                                                                Excellent threadsp2006/10/28 12:38 AM
                                                              Information and ickiness on JavaTzvetan Mikov2006/10/27 05:12 PM
                                                      Language safety in a multithread environmentTzvetan Mikov2006/10/26 08:17 AM
                                                        Language safety in a multithread environmentLinus Torvalds2006/10/26 08:57 AM
                                                          Language safety in a multithread environmentRob Thorpe2006/10/26 09:38 AM
                                                            Language safety in a multithread environmentS. Rao2006/10/26 02:51 PM
                                                              Language safety in a multithread environmentRob Thorpe2006/10/27 01:26 AM
                                                                Language safety in a multithread environmentLinus Torvalds2006/10/27 08:40 AM
                                                                  Language safety in a multithread environmentRob Thorpe2006/10/27 09:06 AM
                                                                    Language safety in a multithread environmentLinus Torvalds2006/10/27 10:53 AM
                                                                      Language safety in a multithread environmentrwessel2006/10/27 03:21 PM
                                                                        Explicit vs implicit barriersTzvetan Mikov2006/10/27 05:39 PM
                                                                          Explicit vs implicit barriersLinus Torvalds2006/10/27 06:28 PM
                                                                            Explicit vs implicit barriersTzvetan Mikov2006/10/28 06:02 PM
                                                                              Explicit vs implicit barriersLinus Torvalds2006/10/28 07:55 PM
                                                                                Explicit vs implicit barriersRob Thorpe2006/10/31 12:37 PM
                                                                            Explicit vs implicit barriersRob Thorpe2006/10/31 12:15 PM
                                                                          Explicit vs implicit barriersrwessel2006/10/27 06:39 PM
                                                                      Why OoO stores are evil but OoO loads are o.k.?Michael S2006/10/28 02:10 PM
                                                                        Why OoO stores are evil but OoO loads are o.k.?Linus Torvalds2006/10/28 04:29 PM
                                                                          Why OoO stores are evil but OoO loads are o.k.?Ricardo B2006/10/30 06:36 AM
                                                                            Why OoO stores are evil but OoO loads are o.k.?Linus Torvalds2006/10/30 09:57 AM
                                                                              Why OoO stores are evil but OoO loads are o.k.?Tzvetan Mikov2006/10/30 11:55 AM
                                                                                Why OoO stores are evil but OoO loads are o.k.?Michael S2006/10/30 12:14 PM
                                                                                  Why OoO stores are evil but OoO loads are o.k.?Tzvetan Mikov2006/10/30 12:20 PM
                                                                                    Why OoO stores are evil but OoO loads are o.k.?Michael S2006/10/30 01:11 PM
                                                                                      A reference would be nice :-) (NT)Tzvetan Mikov2006/10/30 01:32 PM
                                                                                        A reference Michael S2006/10/30 03:37 PM
                                                                                          A reference Tzvetan Mikov2006/11/03 08:57 PM
                                                                                            check your e-mbox (NT)Michael S2006/11/04 12:47 PM
                                                                                      Why OoO stores are evil but OoO loads are o.k.?David Kanter2006/10/30 01:40 PM
                                                                                        Why OoO stores are evil but OoO loads are o.k.?Michael S2006/10/30 02:28 PM
                                                                                          Why OoO stores are evil but OoO loads are o.k.?David Kanter2006/10/30 02:43 PM
                                                                                            Why OoO stores are evil but OoO loads are o.k.?Michael S2006/10/30 04:36 PM
                                                                                              Why OoO stores are evil but OoO loads are o.k.?David Kanter2006/10/30 10:14 PM
                                                                                Why OoO stores are evil but OoO loads are o.k.?Linus Torvalds2006/10/30 12:53 PM
                                                                      Language safety in a multithread environmentRob Thorpe2006/10/31 11:25 AM
                                                                        Language safety in a multithread environmentLinus Torvalds2006/10/31 12:59 PM
                                                                          Language safety in a multithread environmentRob Thorpe2006/10/31 01:38 PM
                                                                            Language safety in a multithread environmentLinus Torvalds2006/10/31 02:02 PM
                                                                              Language safety in a multithread environmentLinus Torvalds2006/10/31 03:54 PM
                                                                                Will reply tommorrow, very busy today (NT)Rob Thorpe2006/11/01 11:14 AM
                                                                              Language safety in a multithread environmentRob Thorpe2006/11/02 01:30 PM
                                                                                Language safety in a multithread environmentrwessel2006/11/02 02:06 PM
                                                                                  Language safety in a multithread environmentGabriele Svelto2006/11/03 02:39 AM
                                                                                    Language safety in a multithread environmentLinus Torvalds2006/11/03 09:40 AM
                                                                                      Language safety in a multithread environmentGabriele Svelto2006/11/03 10:12 AM
                                                                                        Language safety in a multithread environmentLinus Torvalds2006/11/03 01:20 PM
                                                                                          Language safety in a multithread environmentGabriele Svelto2006/11/06 03:42 AM
                                                                                      Language safety in a multithread environmentEric Bron2006/11/04 04:47 AM
                                                                                        Language safety in a multithread environmentGabriele Svelto2006/11/06 04:13 AM
                                                                                      Language safety in a multithread environmentWilco2006/11/04 12:29 PM
                                                                                        Language safety in a multithread environmentRicardo B2006/11/04 02:54 PM
                                                                                        Language safety in a multithread environmentGabriele Svelto2006/11/06 03:54 AM
                                                                                          Language safety in a multithread environmentWilco2006/11/06 12:26 PM
                                                                                            Language safety in a multithread environmentGabriele Svelto2006/11/07 01:54 AM
                                                                                              Language safety in a multithread environmentWilco2006/11/07 04:34 PM
                                                                                                Language safety in a multithread environmentGabriele Svelto2006/11/08 02:29 AM
                                                                                      Language safety in a multithread environmentrwessel2006/11/04 10:13 PM
                                                                                        Language safety in a multithread environmentrwessel2006/11/04 10:23 PM
                                                                                      Language safety in a multithread environmentMichael S2006/11/05 04:05 AM
                                                                                        Language safety in a multithread environmentLinus Torvalds2006/11/05 10:14 AM
                                                                                          unaligned SSE testsEric Bron2006/11/05 02:26 PM
                                                                                            unaligned SSE testsMichael S2006/11/05 03:47 PM
                                                                                              unaligned SSE testsEric Bron2006/11/05 04:23 PM
                                                                                                unaligned SSE testsMichael S2006/11/05 05:03 PM
                                                                                                  unaligned SSE testsEric Bron2006/11/05 05:28 PM
                                                                                                    Now results make sense. How about Psc? (NT)Michael S2006/11/05 05:37 PM
                                                                                                      tomorrow, it's 01:43 PM where I'm (NT)Eric Bron2006/11/05 05:44 PM
                                                                                                        I mean 01:43 AM (NT)Eric Bron2006/11/05 05:45 PM
                                                                                                      PSC scoresEric Bron2006/11/06 02:25 AM
                                                                                                        PSC scoresMichael S2006/11/06 04:28 AM
                                                                                                          PSC scoresIan Ameline2006/11/06 09:00 AM
                                                                                                            meaningful performance gainMichael S2006/11/06 09:33 AM
                                                                                                              meaningful performance gainLinus Torvalds2006/11/06 11:15 AM
                                                                                                                Dynamically resolved alignmentDavid Kanter2006/11/06 12:49 PM
                                                                                                                  Dynamically resolved alignmentRicardo B2006/11/06 01:46 PM
                                                                                                                  Dynamically resolved alignmentLinus Torvalds2006/11/06 01:48 PM
                                                                                                                meaningful performance gainEric Bron2006/11/07 02:23 AM
                                                                                                        RE: "I suppose we will have to continue to align" ...Not really :)redpriest2006/11/06 05:11 PM
                                                                                                          Your point?Michael S2006/11/06 05:47 PM
                                                                                                            Actually Michael, it's quite a bit more than that.redpriest2006/11/06 06:30 PM
                                                                                                              Actually Michael, it's quite a bit more than that.anonymous2006/11/06 08:36 PM
                                                                                                                Actually Michael, it's quite a bit more than that.Linus Torvalds2006/11/06 09:01 PM
                                                                                                                  Actually Michael, it's quite a bit more than that.Rob Thorpe2006/11/07 03:31 AM
                                                                                                                  Actually Michael, it's quite a bit more than that.anonymous2006/11/07 07:27 AM
                                                                                                              link vs linqMichael S2006/11/07 02:04 AM
                                                                                                                link vs linqanonymous2006/11/07 07:13 AM
                                                                                                                  Thank you (NT)Michael S2006/11/07 08:04 AM
                                                                                                          Barcelona dreamsEric Bron2006/11/07 01:08 AM
                                                                                          Language safety in a multithread environmentWilco2006/11/05 03:14 PM
                                                                                            Language safety in a multithread environmentRicardo B2006/11/05 03:56 PM
                                                                                              Language safety in a multithread environmentWilco2006/11/05 06:52 PM
                                                                                                Language safety in a multithread environmentRicardo B2006/11/05 09:09 PM
                                                                                                  Language safety in a multithread environmentWilco2006/11/06 02:25 PM
                                                                                                    Language safety in a multithread environmentRicardo B2006/11/06 03:48 PM
                                                                                                      Language safety in a multithread environmentWilco2006/11/06 04:44 PM
                                                                                                        Language safety in a multithread environmentRicardo B2006/11/06 04:53 PM
                                                                                                        A common problemRob Thorpe2006/11/07 09:45 AM
                                                                                                          A common problemWilco2006/11/09 04:46 PM
                                                                                                            A common problemRob Thorpe2006/11/10 08:29 AM
                                                                                                              A common problemrwessel2006/11/13 04:47 PM
                                                                                                                A common problemWilco2006/11/13 05:51 PM
                                                                                                                  A common problemRob Thorpe2006/11/14 03:38 AM
                                                                                                                    A common problemLinus Torvalds2006/11/14 09:37 AM
                                                                                                                      A common problemRob Thorpe2006/11/14 11:18 AM
                                                                                                                        A common problemagony2006/11/14 02:57 PM
                                                                                                                          A common problemrwessel2006/11/14 04:13 PM
                                                                                                                            A common problemAndi Kleen2006/11/15 04:24 AM
                                                                                                                              A common problemrwessel2006/11/15 04:42 PM
                                                                                                                        A common problemDoug Siebert2006/11/14 09:50 PM
                                                                                                                          x86 versus other platformsDavid Kanter2006/11/15 12:58 AM
                                                                                                                            x86 versus other platformsj2006/11/15 01:57 AM
                                                                                                                          A common problemRob Thorpe2006/11/15 11:56 AM
                                                                                                                            A common problemWilco2006/11/15 01:54 PM
                                                                                                                              A common problemCarlie Coats2006/11/16 06:44 AM
                                                                                                                              A common problemLinus Torvalds2006/11/16 10:03 AM
                                                                                                                      A common problemCarlie Coats2006/11/16 06:38 AM
                                                                                                                        A common problemRob Thorpe2006/11/16 07:29 AM
                                                                                                                    A common problemWilco2006/11/15 02:13 PM
                                                                                                                      A common problemRob Thorpe2006/11/16 09:20 AM
                                                                                                                        A common problemrwessel2006/11/16 04:27 PM
                                                                                                                        A common problemWilco2006/11/17 02:20 PM
                                                                                                                          A common problemRob Thorpe2006/11/20 04:14 AM
                                                                                          You are aiming too lowMichael S2006/11/05 04:19 PM
                                                                                            And you're aiming quite highRob Thorpe2006/11/06 08:00 AM
                                                                                    Language safety in a multithread environmentWilco2006/11/04 11:20 AM
                                                                                      Language safety in a multithread environmentGabriele Svelto2006/11/06 04:10 AM
                                                                                        Language safety in a multithread environmentWilco2006/11/06 10:59 AM
                                                                                          Language safety in a multithread environmentGabriele Svelto2006/11/08 02:47 AM
                                                                                            Language safety in a multithread environmentWilco2006/11/13 05:13 PM
                                                                                              Language safety in a multithread environmentGabriele Svelto2006/11/14 02:15 AM
                                                                                                Language safety in a multithread environmentWilco2006/11/17 02:51 PM
                                                                                    Language safety in a multithread environmentrwessel2006/11/04 10:11 PM
                                                                                  Language safety in a multithread environmentRob Thorpe2006/11/03 09:58 AM
                                                                  Language safety in a multithread environmentbandwidth2006/10/27 06:47 PM
                                                                    Language safety in a multithread environmentLinus Torvalds2006/10/27 07:52 PM
                                                                      Language safety in a multithread environmentLinus Torvalds2006/10/27 08:10 PM
                                                                        Language safety in a multithread environmentbandwidth2006/10/28 03:17 AM
                                                                      Language safety in a multithread environmentbandwidth2006/10/28 03:09 AM
                                                                        Language safety in a multithread environmentLinus Torvalds2006/10/28 09:23 AM
                                                                      Language safety in a multithread environmentGabriele Svelto2006/10/30 03:26 AM
                                                                        Language safety in a multithread environmentRicardo B2006/10/30 06:52 AM
                                                                        Language safety in a multithread environmentJasonB2006/10/30 07:12 AM
                                                                          Language safety in a multithread environmentGabriele Svelto2006/10/30 07:28 AM
                                                                            Language safety in a multithread environmentJasonB2006/10/30 08:32 AM
                                                                              Language safety in a multithread environmentGabriele Svelto2006/10/30 08:48 AM
                                                                                Language safety in a multithread environmentJasonB2006/10/30 09:21 AM
                                                                          Language safety in a multithread environmentRicardo B2006/10/30 07:31 AM
                                                                            Language safety in a multithread environmentGabriele Svelto2006/10/30 07:43 AM
                                                                              Language safety in a multithread environmentRicardo B2006/10/30 07:54 AM
                                                                                Language safety in a multithread environmentGabriele Svelto2006/10/30 08:02 AM
                                                                                  Language safety in a multithread environmentRicardo B2006/10/30 08:12 AM
                                                                                    Language safety in a multithread environmentGabriele Svelto2006/10/30 08:29 AM
                                                                                      Language safety in a multithread environmentRicardo B2006/10/30 08:40 AM
                                                                                Language safety in a multithread environmentdraugaz2006/10/30 12:31 PM
                                                                              Language safety in a multithread environmentLinus Torvalds2006/10/30 10:09 AM
                                                                                Language safety in a multithread environmentGabriele Svelto2006/10/31 02:01 AM
                                                                                  Language safety in a multithread environmentLinus Torvalds2006/10/31 08:59 AM
                                                                    Language safety in a multithread environmentpgerassi2006/10/27 08:00 PM
                                                                      Language safety in a multithread environmentbandwidth2006/10/28 03:25 AM
                                                                        Language safety in a multithread environmentpgerassi2006/10/31 01:32 AM
                                                                      Language safety in a multithread environmentRob Thorpe2006/10/31 06:52 AM
                                                        pythonFoo_2006/10/28 01:51 AM
                                                          pythonTzvetan Mikov2006/10/28 04:55 PM
                                                            pythonFoo_2006/10/29 03:51 AM
                                                          pythonRob Thorpe2006/10/31 05:01 AM
                                        Language safety in a multithread environmentTzvetan Mikov2006/10/24 10:53 AM
                                          Language safety in a multithread environmentRob Thorpe2006/10/25 01:00 AM
                                          Language safety in a multithread environment (Lock-free structures)Ray2006/10/28 11:25 AM
                                            Language safety in a multithread environment (Lock-free structures)Linus Torvalds2006/10/28 11:58 AM
                                              Language safety in a multithread environment (Lock-free structures)Ray2006/10/28 04:47 PM
                                                Language safety in a multithread environment (Lock-free structures)Linus Torvalds2006/10/28 08:02 PM
                                        Language safety in a multithread environmentJuho Snellman2006/10/25 03:59 AM
                                          Language safety in a multithread environmentRob Thorpe2006/10/25 04:38 AM
                                            Language safety in a multithread environmentJuho Snellman2006/10/25 06:38 AM
                                              Language safety in a multithread environmentRob Thorpe2006/10/25 07:06 AM
                                                More on this topicRob Thorpe2006/10/25 08:41 AM
                                                  More on this topicTzvetan Mikov2006/10/25 10:17 AM
                                                    More on this topicRob Thorpe2006/10/26 02:02 AM
                                                Language safety in a multithread environmentJuho Snellman2006/10/25 10:33 AM
                                                  Language safety in a multithread environmentRob Thorpe2006/10/26 01:48 AM
                                      Language safety in a multithread environmentS. Rao2006/10/23 03:40 PM
                                        Language safety in a multithread environmentTzvetan Mikov2006/10/23 11:38 PM
                                        Language safety in a multithread environmentGabriele Svelto2006/10/24 01:02 AM
                                          Language safety in a multithread environmentS. Rao2006/10/24 12:40 PM
                                        Comparison to stack allocationRob Thorpe2006/10/24 03:09 AM
                                          Comparison to stack allocationS. Rao2006/10/24 12:32 PM
                                            Exactly, see my other post (NT)Rob Thorpe2006/10/25 12:53 AM
                          Language safety in a multithread environmentDavid Wragg2006/10/20 02:46 AM
                            Language safety in a multithread environmentTzvetan Mikov2006/10/21 09:24 AM
                          Ugh, evil problemRob Thorpe2006/10/20 03:56 AM
                            Ugh, evil problemGabriele Svelto2006/10/20 04:38 AM
                              Ugh, evil problemRob Thorpe2006/10/20 05:47 AM
                                Ugh, evil problemGabriele Svelto2006/10/20 05:54 AM
                                Ugh, evil problemRicardo B2006/10/20 06:43 AM
                            Ugh, evil problemJasonB2006/10/20 06:17 AM
                              Ugh, evil problemS. Rao2006/10/20 08:09 PM
                                Ugh, evil problemJasonB2006/10/21 07:58 AM
                                SecondedRob Thorpe2006/10/23 01:53 AM
                          Copying GC Rob Thorpe2006/10/23 02:51 AM
                            Copying GC Tzvetan Mikov2006/10/23 11:13 PM
                              Copying GC Rob Thorpe2006/10/24 01:22 AM
              Python + native extensionsFoo_2006/10/18 02:29 PM
                Python + native extensionssp2006/10/19 01:05 AM
  z9 - Power5 connection?foobar2006/10/17 01:15 PM
    z9 - Power5 connection?David Kanter2006/10/17 02:03 PM
      z9 - Power5 connection?foobar2006/10/17 02:33 PM
        z9 - Power5 connection?rwessel2006/10/17 07:39 PM
          z9 - Power5 connection?foobar2006/10/17 08:38 PM
            Sounds like I should edit the article...David Kanter2006/10/17 10:48 PM
            z9 - Power5 connection?Jesper Frimann2006/10/17 11:59 PM
Reply to this Topic
Name:
Email:
Topic:
Body: No Text
How do you spell avocado?