By: Gabriele Svelto (gabriele.svelto.delete@this.gmail.com),
Room: Moderated Discussions
john.doe (jd.delete@this.example.com) on July 18, 2019 10:50 am wrote:
> I was leaning towards a Xeon E but Xeon E-2200s are still not shipping (despite being announced
> some time ago) and Ryzen is shipping, Intel made the choice for me to buy AMD.
>
> Ryzen lacks officially supported ECC though some motherboard vendors
> claim to have it validated, that might be the best I can do.
I've been running a Ryzen 2700X w/ 32 GiB of ECC memory on an ASUS PRIME B450-PLUS for a few months now and it's working just fine. On Linux rasdaemon monitors and reports errors correctly, Windows detects the ECC functionality (though I don't know how to monitor errors there) and memtest86 also does. I've even deliberately overclocked the ECC memory so that it would start generating (and correcting) errors and they showed up in memtest86 just as I expected them to.
> I was leaning towards a Xeon E but Xeon E-2200s are still not shipping (despite being announced
> some time ago) and Ryzen is shipping, Intel made the choice for me to buy AMD.
>
> Ryzen lacks officially supported ECC though some motherboard vendors
> claim to have it validated, that might be the best I can do.
I've been running a Ryzen 2700X w/ 32 GiB of ECC memory on an ASUS PRIME B450-PLUS for a few months now and it's working just fine. On Linux rasdaemon monitors and reports errors correctly, Windows detects the ECC functionality (though I don't know how to monitor errors there) and memtest86 also does. I've even deliberately overclocked the ECC memory so that it would start generating (and correcting) errors and they showed up in memtest86 just as I expected them to.
Thread (26 posts)
| Topic | Posted By | Posted |
|---|---|---|
| Xeon E or Xeon W or Zen 2? | john.doe | |
| Xeon E or Xeon W or Zen 2? | anon | |
| Xeon E or Xeon W or Zen 2? | Adrian | |
| Xeon E or Xeon W or Zen 2? | anon | |
| Xeon E or Xeon W or Zen 2? | Adrian | |
| Xeon E or Xeon W or Zen 2? | anon | |
| Xeon E or Xeon W or Zen 2? | Adrian | |
| Xeon E or Xeon W or Zen 2? | Travis Downs | |
| Xeon E or Xeon W or Zen 2? | Chester | |
| PCIe4 SSDs | Michael S | |
| PCIe4 SSDs | Adrian | |
| PCIe4 SSDs | anon | |
| Xeon E or Xeon W or Zen 2? | john.doe | |
| Xeon E or Xeon W or Zen 2? | Adrian | |
| Xeon E or Xeon W or Zen 2? | john.doe | |
| Xeon E or Xeon W or Zen 2? | Gabriele Svelto | |
| Xeon E or Xeon W or Zen 2? | john.doe | |
| Xeon E or Xeon W or Zen 2? | Gabriele Svelto | |
| Xeon E or Xeon W or Zen 2? | Peter E. Fry | |
| Xeon E or Xeon W or Zen 2? | Nicolas Carranza | |
| Xeon E or Xeon W or Zen 2? | Gabriele Svelto | |
| Xeon E or Xeon W or Zen 2? | Maxwell | |
| Xeon E or Xeon W or Zen 2? | Nicolas Carranza | |
| Xeon E or Xeon W or Zen 2? | anon³ | |
| Xeon E or Xeon W or Zen 2? | Maxwell | |
| Xeon E or Xeon W or Zen 2? | David Hess |


